Will Manifold Dating have single sign-on with Manifold on November, 20th?
44
401
853
resolved Nov 20
Resolved
NO

Resolves:

  • YES if users visiting app (manifold.love or whatever if the domain is changed) are logged in automatically;

  • 70% if users will have to press "sign in" button, but get authenticated by manifold.markets (clarification: with no additional clicks; redirects are OK);

  • NO if users will have to sign in with their Google/Apple account separately (P.S: for instance, if they see Google sign-in popup that allows to choose account or asks for permissions).

Get Ṁ200 play money

🏅 Top traders

#NameTotal profit
1Ṁ241
2Ṁ130
3Ṁ108
4Ṁ37
5Ṁ18
Sort by:

I've just checked: "Sign up as matchmaker" button opens Google auth popup. Thus, this resolves NO.

bought Ṁ150 of YES

You can now click "sign-in" and log in as your existing Manifold account, so unless this is reverted before market close, this should resolve to 70% at least.

predicted YES

@chrisjbillington In fact, creating an account on manifold.love already is the same thing as creating a regular manifold.markets account, the authentication is already the same. But some users logged into manifold.love have dating profiles and some don't - the ones that don't are "match-makers" only until they make one.

bought Ṁ60 of YES

@AnT on this point though:

  • NO if users will have to sign in with their Google/Apple account separately.

The login is a google login popup still, but since this is how logging into Manifold works anyway, I take it you won't resolve NO on this basis. There is only one database table of users for both manifold and manifold.love, and all of them can login to manifold.love. There is an additional database table of dating profiles, but each is associated with a user in the main database table, and you can be logged in without one.

sold Ṁ206 of YES

@AnT thanks for the managram, and I was able to sell without making a loss anyway, but now I'm not really sure what you were going for with this market. Logging in with google is how one logs into Manifold normally, so if you're excluding that then it seems like a YES resolution would require manifold.markets to change the way they do login generally as well as unify this with manifold.love.

@chrisjbillington Clarified resolution criteria.

I'm thinking about the following: on manifold.love user clicks sign-in button, is redirected to manifold.markets, and Manifold gives the needed access tokens to Manifold Dating during this process.

@AnT Thanks, that makes sense!

bought Ṁ50 of NO

Seems like a bad idea

@Shump Any chance that you could elaborate on this?