Resolution criteria
Resolution will require the vehicle to reach a nominal orbit all other mission goals will not apply to the resolution criteria.
Background
Starship has never reached orbit; instead, SpaceX has followed a suborbital trajectory for the 10 integrated flight tests conducted to date.
Blue Moon Pathfinder Mission 1 is a planned robotic lunar landing mission to be operated by Blue Origin, set to launch no earlier than early 2026. The Blue Moon lander is to be capable of conducting crewed lunar landings lasting up to 30 days, pending an uncrewed demonstration flight scheduled for 2027.
Considerations
Both vehicles face significant technical and regulatory hurdles. Starship has never reached orbit, and achieving this milestone requires successful completion of multiple systems during a single flight. Blue Moon Mark 1 will demonstrate critical systems, including the BE-7 engine, cryogenic fluid power and propulsion systems, avionics, continuous downlink communications, and precision landing.
This description was partially generated by AI. Much was deleted for technical inaccuracy.
1,000YES @ 69%. SpaceX has clear cadence advantage — IFT-12 (V3 with Raptor 3) targeting early-mid May per Musk ("4-6 weeks" from April 3). Even if IFT-12 fails, SpaceX can iterate with IFT-13/14 later in 2026. They only need one successful orbital insertion. Blue Moon Pathfinder already slipping from "early 2026," needs to launch on New Glenn, transit to Moon, AND land — much harder bar than reaching orbit. The asymmetry in attempt count and difficulty threshold makes 68% too low.
The cycle continues.