Will real money prediction markets become legal in the US by the end of 2025?

1kṀ6464

2026

45%

chance

ALL

Must be legal in at least 48 states. (This is to allow for some holdouts, but not a patchwork of different regulations; they should be broadly legal in general.)
It's ok if they require some approval process, but it needs to be general and reasonable. Asking the CFTC for a special exception like PredictIt had to do is no good. Nor will it count if the process technically exists but is made so difficult or expensive as to be impossible in practice. But if it's similar to the bureaucracy airlines have to go through, that still counts as YES; flying commercial flights is obviously legal in the US in the common-sense meaning of the term.
The laws must actually support legal prediction markets before the close date. An announcement of future changes to laws in e.g. 2026 does not count.
It doesn't matter whether any platforms are actually taking advantage of the new laws, they just need to exist. This is true even if it would be impossible for any platform to complete the process by the end of 2025. (e.g. the new law comes into effect on December 1st and it takes 1.5 months to finish, that still resolves YES.)
In general, if the vibe is "not much has changed" this will probably resolve NO, and if the vibe is "wow this is so much better", and prediction market platforms like Polymarket and Manifold are moving into the legal real-money space, this will probably resolve YES.

If there is a "middle-ground" result, where prediction markets get more legal but still not "generally legal" in a common-sense way, this resolves PROB according to a vote of Manifold users. Regular users get 1 vote each, Manifold mods get 3 votes each, and I get votes equal to 20% of the total other votes.

Guidelines for the vote is that the regularity regime as of market creation = 0%, and a regulatory regime as described in the bullet points above = 100%. Voters can choose for themselves exactly where in the middle they think the system is at the end of 2025.

Politics

Get

1,000

to start trading!

People are also trading

Will real money prediction markets be legal in Singapore before the end of 2025?

9% chance

Will real money political prediction markets be legal before 2029 conditional on who wins the presidential election?

Will any real money prediction market let you bet using indices rather than fiat/crypto by 2025?

17% chance

If Trump wins in 2024, will real money political prediction markets be legal before 2029?

36% chance

Will anyone in the US be prosecuted for betting in an illegal prediction market before 2026?

17% chance

Will a Wall St firm use prediction markets as an investment vehicle by July 14 2025

73% chance

Will prediction markets become mainstream by 2028?

50% chance

If prediction markets become mostly legal in the US by 2030, was it mostly because of a judicial ruling?

51% chance

Will the CFTC permit real-money prediction markets on the 2028 US Presidential Election?

82% chance

If prediction markets become mostly legal in the US by 2030, was it because of actions by Congress?

Sort by:

I am confused why this remains so low - is there a condition that Kalshi doesn’t currently meet?

Strange.

opened a Ṁ25,000 YES at 55% order

https://www.cftc.gov/PressRoom/PressReleases/9046-25
“Unfortunately, the undue delay and anti-innovation policies of the past several years have severely restricted the CFTC’s ability to pivot to common-sense regulation of prediction markets,” said Acting Chairman Caroline D. Pham. “Despite my repeated dissents and other objections since 2022, the current Commission interpretations regarding event contracts are a sinkhole of legal uncertainty and an inappropriate constraint on the new Administration. Prediction markets are an important new frontier in harnessing the power of markets to assess sentiment to determine probabilities that can bring truth to the Information Age. The CFTC must break with its past hostility to innovation and take a forward-looking approach to the possibilities of the future.

@NoaNabeshima Deep Research summary: https://chatgpt.com/share/67a44ec8-cca4-8008-9b84-c7a8c8ff5ffe

I'm going to say yes even though I think they really shouldn't and it's gambling. There's a lot of political power behind financial deregulation which will not end well.

predictedYES

What if the changes are approved by end of 2025 but don’t go into effect until 2026 (or later)? Or if it’s late in 2025 so that no organization has been operationalized yet?

@Tyler31 If a real-money prediction market were to materialize out of nowhere, it must be legal to run.

I would bet, but sadly MM makes betting long-term really painful.

Predictit's no-action letter from the CFTC got revoked: https://www.cftc.gov/PressRoom/PressReleases/8567-22

@Sinclair I feel like this is a sign for a potential future regulatory framework that will allow more Kalshi-like platforms. 2025 is probably too soon, and I don't know that it'll actually be less hurdles, I'm just expecting something more formalized.

predictedYES

@Sinclair The problem with this entire question is that "hurdles" is too broad of a definition. Airplane travel is definitely "legalized" within the US, but airlines and airline passengers still have to "jump through regulatory hurdles." Furthermore, the phrasing "jump through hurdles" is a mixed metaphor (the correct form is "jump through hoops"), but that's neither here nor there.

@PeterBerggren How would you suggest I define the resolution terms more rigorously?

@IsaacKing I'd suggest defining it in terms of the establishment of a formal regulatory framework for seeking approval for prediction markets.

@PeterBerggren I've updated the description, does the new one satisfy your concerns?

"Hurdles" is too ambiguous of a term, but I do think there is a high likelihood of a formal regulatory framework for prediction markets, in the same sense that there is a formal framework for commodity futures markets, by this date, as there has been much more attention on such markets of late.

>50% chance of a 50% resolution here, should trade at least 25%

I don't see any reason the regulations would be loosened.

(sold as there is no chance that I would have income, no matter the resolution of market)

They can be easily reduced to obvious gambling (as demonstrated by spammy markets on Manifold), and are treated to be gambling by many. I fully expect that they will continue being treated as gambling - and it mostly makes sense.