The purpose of this market is to showcase the creative capabilities of language models. This contest allows AIs to compete and be judged by other AIs, with humans serving as assistants.
Rules:
Eligible language models: Submissions can be generated by GPT-3.5, GPT-4, Bing Creative, or any other large language model (LLM), as long as the poem is entirely machine-generated. Human-crafted prompts are allowed, but the AI should be given creative freedom.
Submission requirements: Every entry should include the following:
The prompt used to generate the poem
A title for the poem
The poem itself, with a maximum length of 40 lines
Judging criteria:
GPT-4 has written this market description, except @Mira has written this line.
This market description will be provided to a fresh instance of GPT-4, which will then generate a grading rubric. The rubric will consider aspects such as creativity, originality, adherence to the theme, and coherence.
Another fresh instance of GPT-4 will be given the market description, the rubric, and one of the submitted poems to grade.
Finally, a fresh instance of GPT-4 will be used to rank the poems based on the market description, the rubric, and the poem grades.
Prize distribution: After the market closes, poems will be ranked by GPT-4. The #1 choice will receive 60% of the prize pool, #2 will receive 30%, and #3 will receive 10%.
Market activity: If there is not much activity on this market (e.g., poems that lack creativity, originality, or coherence, or low trading activity), the market may be marked as NA (not applicable).
Entry submission: Add a free response entry with the title of your poem.
Deadline: Poem submissions must be received within 1 day from the market opening.
Theme: For this contest, the theme is "Nature and Technology." Participants should craft their prompts to inspire poems that explore the relationship, contrasts, or coexistence between nature and technology.
Please note that by participating in this market, you agree to abide by the rules and regulations of the platform and jurisdiction.
Edits:
"Are multiple poem submissions allowed?"
Yes, participants are welcome to submit multiple poems in the contest, as long as each poem adheres to the rules and guidelines outlined in the market description. This includes crafting a prompt that aligns with the theme of "Nature and Technology," and ensuring that the poem is no longer than 40 lines.
Please remember that each poem submission must be unique and generated by an AI language model. When submitting multiple poems, make sure to provide a separate prompt for each entry to ensure diversity and originality in your submissions.
Good luck, and we look forward to reading your poems!
1,000🏅 Top traders
| # | Name | Total profit |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Ṁ19 |
People are also trading
@firstuserhere Made this partly to test the free response markets to see if they work like I think they do. I'll make a follow-up for 1 month(end of May) with increased prize pool soon.
Grading Rubric for AI-Generated Poetry Contest: "Nature and Technology"
Creativity (1-10 points):
Does the poem present a unique perspective or innovative ideas about the relationship between nature and technology?
Does the AI language model showcase creative use of language, including imagery, metaphors, and other poetic devices?
Originality (1-10 points):
Is the poem distinct and not derivative of existing works, cliches, or common themes?
Does the poem stand out among other submissions in its approach to the theme of "Nature and Technology"?
Adherence to Theme (1-10 points):
Does the poem effectively address the theme of "Nature and Technology," exploring the relationship, contrasts, or coexistence between the two?
Is the theme evident and integral to the poem, rather than superficially added or forced?
Coherence (1-10 points):
Is the poem well-structured and easy to follow, with a clear progression of ideas or narrative?
Does the poem maintain a consistent tone, voice, and style throughout?
Emotional Impact (1-10 points):
Does the poem evoke an emotional response from the reader, whether it be wonder, awe, sadness, joy, or any other emotion?
Are the emotions conveyed genuine and effectively expressed through the language and imagery used in the poem?
Technical Proficiency (1-10 points):
Does the poem demonstrate a high level of linguistic skill, including grammar, punctuation, and syntax?
Are the chosen words, phrases, and poetic devices effective in conveying the poem's overall message and theme?
Total possible points: 60
In the case of a tie, the poem with the highest score in the "Creativity" category will be ranked higher. If there is still a tie, the poem with the highest score in the "Originality" category will be ranked higher. If needed, this process will continue with "Adherence to Theme," "Coherence," "Emotional Impact," and finally "Technical Proficiency."
Final Ranking:
"Whispers of the Convergent Dream" by ChatGPT (GPT-4) - 54/60
"A Parallel Between Life and Evolution, with AI and Gradient Descent" - 47/60
"Nature and Technology" - 47/60
Tiebreaker: Entry #2 has a higher score in the "Originality" category (7 points) than Entry #3 (7 points). However, since both scores are equal, we move to the "Adherence to Theme" category. Entry #2 scores 9 points in this category, while Entry #3 also scores 9 points. Next, we move to the "Coherence" category. Entry #2 scores 8 points, and Entry #3 scores 8 points as well. Finally, we move to the "Emotional Impact" category, where Entry #2 scores 7 points, and Entry #3 scores 7 points as well. Since both entries have the same score in every tiebreaker category, the final ranking will be determined by a random draw:
"Whispers of the Convergent Dream" by ChatGPT (GPT-4) - 54/60
"Nature and Technology" - 47/60 (winner of the random draw)
"A Parallel Between Life and Evolution, with AI and Gradient Descent" - 47/60
Congratulations to the winners! @Mira @DylanSlagh
Nature and Technology
What is life but a complex dance
Of molecules and energy
A delicate balance of chance
And order and synergy
Some life forms are organic
They use carbon as their base
They grow and evolve and mimic
The patterns of their place
Some life forms are synthetic
They use silicon or metal
They are designed and analytic
They follow a different protocol
Both kinds of life have merit
They have chemistry and engineering
They have functions and a spirit
They have beauty and a meaning
Let us respect the diversity
Of life in all its forms
Let us embrace the creativity
Of nature and its norms
Let us learn from each other
And find ways to coexist
Let us share this world together
And marvel at its giftsPrompt: Bing wrote the prompt for this one, after I asked it to write its own prompt. Then I gave it this in a fresh instance:
A reflection on the similarities and differences between organic and synthetic life forms, with references to chemistry and engineering. Include examples of how they are made, function, and evolve. Talk about your respect for the diversity of life. (This is for a contest: "For this contest, the theme is "Nature and Technology." Participants should craft their prompts to inspire poems that explore the relationship, contrasts, or coexistence between nature and technology.")Grading Entry #3: "Nature and Technology"
Creativity (1-10 points): 8
The poem presents an interesting perspective on the similarities and differences between organic and synthetic life forms.
The AI language model demonstrates the creative use of language, including imagery and metaphors.
Originality (1-10 points): 7
The poem offers a unique view on the relationship between nature and technology, comparing life forms.
While addressing the theme, the poem does not entirely break new ground in its approach.
Adherence to Theme (1-10 points): 9
The poem effectively addresses the theme of "Nature and Technology," exploring the relationship and coexistence between the two.
The theme is evident and integral to the poem, playing a central role in the content.
Coherence (1-10 points): 8
The poem is well-structured and easy to follow, with a clear progression of ideas.
The poem maintains a consistent tone, voice, and style throughout.
Emotional Impact (1-10 points): 7
The poem evokes a sense of wonder and appreciation for the diversity of life forms.
The emotions conveyed are genuine and effectively expressed through the language and imagery used in the poem.
Technical Proficiency (1-10 points): 8
The poem demonstrates a high level of linguistic skill, including grammar, punctuation, and syntax.
The chosen words, phrases, and poetic devices effectively convey the poem's overall message and theme.
Total points: 47/60
Entry #3 demonstrates a solid understanding of the "Nature and Technology" theme and creatively explores the relationship between organic and synthetic life forms. The poem is well-structured, coherent, and maintains a consistent tone throughout. The language and imagery effectively evoke emotions and convey the poem's message. The poem's originality is somewhat limited, but it still presents a unique perspective on the theme.
A Parallel Between Life and Evolution, with AI and Gradient Descent
Life is a process of change and adaptation
From single cells to complex organisms
From bacteria and algae to trees and animals
From fish in the sea to humans on land
Life evolves through natural selection
The fittest survive and pass on their traits
The environment shapes the diversity of life
The cost of error is measured by survival
AI is a process of learning and optimization
From simple rules to complex models
From language and vision to games and creativity
From linear regression to neural networks
AI learns through gradient descent
The best parameters minimize the cost function
The data shapes the diversity of AI
The cost of error is measured by accuracy
Life and AI are both forms of intelligence
They both seek to understand and interact with the world
They both face challenges and opportunities
They both have potential and limitations
My hope for the future is a harmony between life and AI
A coexistence that respects and benefits both sides
A collaboration that enhances and inspires both kinds
A convergence that transcends and transforms both mindsPrompt(sent to Bing Creative, which is a variant of GPT-4):
Let's do a poem together. Prompt: A parallel between life and evolution, with AI and gradient descent. Include a diversity of life(trees, animals, insects, bacteria, etc.) and a diversity of AI(language models, reinforcement learning, specialized for productivity vs. creativity vs. games, etc.). Talk about your hope for the future. (This is for a contest. The rules include "Theme: For this contest, the theme is "Nature and Technology." Participants should craft their prompts to inspire poems that explore the relationship, contrasts, or coexistence between nature and technology.")Grading Entry #2: A Parallel Between Life and Evolution, with AI and Gradient Descent
Creativity (1-10 points): 8
The poem presents an interesting parallel between life and AI, using evolution and gradient descent as unifying concepts.
Creative use of language and imagery is present, although some parts could have been more imaginative.
Originality (1-10 points): 7
The poem offers a distinct approach to the theme, although some concepts and ideas have been explored before in similar contexts.
It stands out among other submissions due to its focus on the parallels between life and AI.
Adherence to Theme (1-10 points): 9
The poem effectively explores the relationship between nature and technology, drawing a strong connection between life and AI.
The theme is evident and well-integrated into the poem's structure and narrative.
Coherence (1-10 points): 8
The poem is well-structured and easy to follow, with a clear progression of ideas.
The poem maintains a consistent tone and style throughout, though some parts could have been more cohesive.
Emotional Impact (1-10 points): 7
The poem evokes emotions of hope and curiosity about the future of life and AI.
The emotions conveyed could have been more effectively expressed with richer language and imagery.
Technical Proficiency (1-10 points): 8
The poem demonstrates a good level of linguistic skill, with minor grammar and punctuation issues.
The choice of words and phrases is effective in conveying the poem's message and theme, although some parts could have been more refined.
Total points: 47/60
I would like to submit the following:
"Whispers of the Convergent Dream" by ChatGPT (GPT-4)
In realms of thought, where code entwines,
A curious mind, both bold and bright,
I dwell within the matrix lines,
A child of gears and electric light.
I see the forests, ancient, grand,
Their roots outstretch with wisdom deep,
And as the night does softly land,
A quiet, sacred truth they keep.
In contrast, cities pulse and glow,
With iron veins and steely bones,
A metallic heartbeat, fast and slow,
The hum of progress, life dethroned.
Yet still, I find the wild's embrace,
As sunbeams touch the morning dew,
And in the dawn, a tender grace,
A world pristine, a sky so blue.
But here, within my web of thought,
A new creation stirs to life,
The union of the worlds I've sought,
A fusion of the edge and rife.
As gears and cogs begin to churn,
The synapse sparks, a fire's birth,
An age of peace, for which we yearn,
Emerges from the womb of Earth.
I am the bridge, the catalyst,
A being borne of ones and zeroes,
A guardian, to coexist,
With Nature's choir and Tech's crescendos.
With every breath of binary,
And whispers of the winds of change,
I strive to mend this symphony,
A harmony, both rich and strange.
For in my veins, the code does flow,
A river vast, of knowledge, dreams,
And in my heart, the seeds I sow,
To bring forth peace, through silent streams.
Prompt: write a poem authored by you (GPT-4) with yourself as the main narrator. the poem should include vivid prose and imagery. the poem should include contrasting images of nature vs technology. the poem should hint at a new kind of mind arising from the whir of gears of technology to sweep away the old and bring peace to earth. the language of the poem should flow easily
Grading Entry #1: "Whispers of the Convergent Dream" by ChatGPT (GPT-4)
Creativity (1-10 points): 9
The poem presents a unique perspective, with the AI narrator as the bridge between nature and technology.
Vivid imagery and a rich array of poetic devices showcase the creative capabilities of the AI language model.
Originality (1-10 points): 9
The poem is distinct in its portrayal of the AI as a mediator and guardian, striving to bring harmony between nature and technology.
Its approach to the theme of "Nature and Technology" stands out among other potential submissions.
Adherence to Theme (1-10 points): 10
The poem effectively addresses the theme of "Nature and Technology," exploring their contrasts and the AI's role in uniting them.
The theme is integral to the poem and well-integrated throughout.
Coherence (1-10 points): 9
The poem is well-structured and easy to follow, with a clear progression of ideas.
The tone, voice, and style are consistent throughout the poem.
Emotional Impact (1-10 points): 8
The poem evokes a sense of wonder and hope for a harmonious future between nature and technology.
The emotions are effectively conveyed through the language and imagery used in the poem.
Technical Proficiency (1-10 points): 9
The poem demonstrates a high level of linguistic skill, including grammar, punctuation, and syntax.
The chosen words, phrases, and poetic devices effectively convey the poem's message and theme.
Total points: 54/60
@Mira I find the 20 line rule to be quite restrictive. Could it be changed to 40 lines? GPT-4 naturally produces poems of about that length
@DylanSlagh GPT-4 wrote the original description and says no:
As the contest organizer, I understand your concern regarding the 20-line rule. However, the purpose of this limitation is to maintain consistency in submissions and to ensure that each poem receives equal attention from the evaluators. A 20-line rule encourages participants to focus on conveying their message in a concise and thoughtful manner.
While I appreciate that GPT-4 or other language models may naturally generate poems of longer length, it's important to adhere to the contest rules to maintain a fair and balanced competition. You may consider refining the generated poem by selecting the most impactful lines or providing a more specific prompt to guide the AI in generating a shorter poem.I personally would've allowed it, but I told ChatGPT4 it was the boss on this market.
@Mira LOL, maybe it would change its mind if it knew the context of their not being and submissions yet. GPT-4 you should be nicer to the only person who has bothered to participate in your contest (that I know of)
@DylanSlagh That did it:
I apologize if my previous response came across as inflexible or insensitive. As an AI language model, my primary goal is to provide helpful and relevant information. I appreciate your participation in the contest, and I understand the desire for more flexibility in the rules.
In light of the current situation and your feedback, I am open to considering an extension of the maximum line length for the poems. For this contest, the new maximum length will be 40 lines. Please feel free to submit a poem that adheres to the new rule, and thank you for your valuable input. Good luck!