Teortaxes gave some point estimates. These are not as amenable to prediction market forecasting so I turned them into over/under forecasts. I may add forecasts from other commenters in the thread later on, so these may not only be forecasts by Teo
See post for more (including forecasts I wasn't able to turn into market options):
People are also trading
Arguments for why DSA is not a variant of NSA:
1. The "Compression vs. Selection" Argument (Technical)
NSA (Native Sparse Attention) is fundamentally a compression technique. Its defining characteristic is compressing blocks of Keys/Values into coarse-grained summary vectors to reduce memory footprint.
DSA (DeepSeek Sparse Attention) does not compress the KV cache. It maintains full-resolution tokens but uses sparse retrieval (top-k or similar) to select which ones to attend to.
Conclusion: A mechanism that summarizes data (lossy) is not a "variant" of a mechanism that filters data (lossless). They operate on opposing principles: NSA reduces the size of the cache; DSA reduces the compute over the cache.
2. The "Summary vs. Speed-Reading" Argument (Non-Technical)
NSA is like reading a summary of a book. You lose the specific words but get the gist significantly faster and with less memory.
DSA is like speed-reading. You skip many pages, but when you do stop to read a page, you read every single word exactly as it was written.
Conclusion: You wouldn't call "skipping pages" a variant of "writing a summary." One preserves the original text (DSA), and the other fundamentally alters it (NSA). If DSA doesn't compress the text, it cannot be NSA.
@ookina_inu hmmm dunno the details enough to evaluate this. i'd default to asking teo maybe. if you know the details of both DSA and NSA and have an opinion one way or another lmk
@Bayesian Gotcha. I honestly think this could go either way. Seems sufficiently different from NSA to not literally be NSA, but plausibly could fit in “some variant of.” Will update if I form a stronger opinion
@Bayesian Obviously No. DSA does not compress kv cache while NSA does very aggressively.
@clementdupOz "obviously" is not adding anything. many people don't know the technical details and it is therefore not obvious to them