As many of you know, I am currently enrolled in a New York (State) private school. After the /realDonaldTrump/am-i-screwed-read-desc incident, along with a bunch of other, let's say, interesting stuff that my school administration has done, I've decided to go to public high school after I graduate middle school this year. Here's my reasoning:
Pro-private (random order):
I have friends there and I haven't been in the public school system for 4 years
It's a nice campus, they have good food, etc.
They have a really cool original science research program (my public HS has this too, but I think it's not as good)
They have Latin, which I'm already taking and I'd have to switch languages
May or may not have slightly better college counseling/matriculation, though it's not as good compared to other private schools
Possibly better academics, but my public HS is supposed to be pretty good too
Pro-public (also random order):
Private school is really expensive
Private school did some crazy stuff this year that we didn't like
Math at public is supposed to be better than at my current school
Shorter commute (1hr vs. 10 mins)
Shorter school day (8am-2:30pm vs 7:45am-5pm)
Private school requires like 90 mins/day of team sports and weekend games, which is not a killer but it's a lot of time
Private school got rid of APs because they said they were racist (?)
Public school is more intellectually diverse, my private school is super duper woke
After one semester of public school, I'll decide whether I regret the decision or not. Resolves YES if I do, ORN. I'll provide reasoning. I still technically haven't filed the papers to go to public yet, so for some reason if I end up going to my current school/a different private school next year, resolves N/A.
Also, I know I doxxed myself the other day so it wouldn't be hard for you to find what school I go to and who I was talking about in the Am I Screwed market, but please don't do that for everyone's safety.
People are also trading
Hey are you guys gonna be ready to futarchy my course selections in a couple months?
@realDonaldTrump you should learn Chinese if it's an option. I'm learning it now and I wish that I had done so much earlier when my brain was younger. It is the second language with the highest earning potential increase for English as a first language speakers.
@BlackCrusade It's probably the most useful of the languages they offer (Spanish, French, Chinese) but the problem is that it's the most challenging (and probably most time consuming) and world languages aren't really my focus right now.
@EnopoletusHarding and that one country is arguably one of if not the most important country economically on earth.
@realDonaldTrump I would say it's the most fun of the languages though. If you do something like Hack Chinese alongside an offered course you will likely do very well.
@ookina_inu This is a perfect Rationalist answer, where social & personal development are seen as irrelevant
@ookina_inu Yes, I completely agree that's the best use of my time, but I doubt my parents are of the same mindset.
What do you recommend I focus on during my newfound free time each day, in the same mindset as your previous response?
If your state has an early college program, take it! You get college and high school credit for taking college courses, which saves tons of money in the long run and makes you smarter faster. Then you’ll come out of it being the youngest member of your friend groups, which confers some advantages at the cost of completely warping your social development/maturity. It’s great fun!
CO has these programs, not sure about NY
@realDonaldTrump find ways of getting into academic research. You have the right mind for it I think (assuming you find it interesting)
@ChurlishGambit that's why I recommend all young people do a short stint in juvie too. it's good for their character development
@realDonaldTrump become an influencer. in the future the only real capital will be social capital. or study statistical learning theory and do hft on real money prediction markets with claude
@ChurlishGambit erm, actually, if you're 13+ it's allowed
(don't tell anyone, but I joined when I was 12.85)
Additional pros and cons I see, thinking longer term than just these next 4 years:
Switching schools is always a huge stressor, but it's lessened greatly when you do it in the divide between middle -> high; a lot of people will be new to each other anyway and high school friends are more important than middle school friends in your development, generally speaking
Intellectual and socioeconomic diversity is important for building soft skills, resiliency, and compassion; leaving your bubble is a strong Pro for your development as a worthwhile human...
... but possibly a Con when thinking about longterm financial success
More time without school is a Con unless you fill it with extracurriculars, but it also means you have more availability for said extracurriculars which is good
Public school will give you more opportunities to stand out from the herd in academics and extracurriculars, which is good for college applications
The time and money cost of private school might have negative downstream effects on your wellbeing that hinder your ability to thrive there and therefore set you back longterm
Private school will usually have better connections to colleges, opportunities for scholarships + interviews, and access to valuable alumni networks
APs (or IBs) are CRITICAL for thriving in college. That alone strikes me personally as a dealbreaker against the private school
My advice? Always choose the scariest option when the fear is Fear of the Unknown.
More time without school is a Con unless you fill it with extracurriculars, but it also means you have more availability for said extracurriculars which is good
re: extracurriculars, I pretty much do a lot of my extracurriculars (amateur astronomy gear+software, vibecoding, manifold) during class anyway, and I don't plan to change this, but I expect to accomplish a lot this year in terms of goals I've set for myself (including starting a company that relates to one of my interests). also see: /realDonaldTrump/will-the-best-thing-i-have-ever-per
In my experience starting over with no friends is rough for the first couple of years (so resolving in the first semester might predispose towards YES).
On the academic side, private school teachers tend to be more supportive vs public school teachers who a lot of times just don't even care/are burned out (but AP teachers are usually good. If APs are important to you, I'd ask whether the AP teachers at the public school have graded AP exams in the past; it tends to be a good predictor of teaching skill).
If you're concerned about the counseling, it might cost less to go to public school and hire a private counselor (depends on the exact pricing of both).