Will anyone be killed by falling space debris before the end of 2032?
5%
chance

Posting because I think the title of this reddit post is probably incorrect and want a market about it

Note: to an extent I am relying on the market participants providing such a story. I will intentionally wait 1 month to resolve in case such a report comes late.

Get Ṁ500 play money

Related questions

Will the Space Drugs Factory be granted reentry prior to World Aids Day?
Mirek avatarQuantum Gambler
56% chance
Will there be a manned interstellar mission before 2250?
Sailfish avatarSailfish
47% chance
Will there be a fatal space accident before 2030?
HalilBabilli avatarHalil Babilli
39% chance
Will a human intentionally kill another human in space by 2050?
lukres avatarlukres
35% chance
Will any spaceship exceed 10% of the speed of light relative to its planet of origin before 9999?
JonathanRay avatarJonathan Ray
60% chance
By 2030, will an organisation be manufacturing products in Earth orbit?
JoshuaWilkes avatarJosh Wilkes
72% chance
Will there be a manned outer planets mission before 2100?
Sailfish avatarSailfish
54% chance
Will humans have sex in space by 2030?
AlexLiesman avatarAlex...
50% chance
Will we mine an asteroid by 2034?
RaviKiran avatarRavi Kiran
26% chance
Will over 1000 people live permanently outside Earth's atmosphere by 2050?
Will there be 100 people in space at the same time before 2030?
IsaacKing avatarIsaac
27% chance
Will someone die aboard a SpaceX rocket before the end of 2030?
wispyartichoke avatarwispy-artichoke
15% chance
By 2040, will an organisation be mining asteroids for resources?
JoshuaWilkes avatarJosh Wilkes
38% chance
Will anyone in a MrBeast video be flown into Space before 2025?
Blomfilter avatarBlomfilter
66% chance
Will there be wonders in the sky by 2050?
lukres avatarlukres
60% chance
Will we have a terrestrial space elevator by 2150?
Tomoffer avatarTom Offer
33% chance
Will the ISS still be in operation at the start of 2030?
Will a human land on any celestial body other than Earth, the Moon, or Mars before 2040?
IsaacKing avatarIsaac
30% chance
Will more than 4500 objects be launched into space in 2023?
Pepe avatarPepe
23% chance
Will a massive solar storm occur before 2050?
Sort by:
Nikola avatar
Nikola

The methodology in the actual paper where they calculated the risk seems roughly right: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41550-022-01718-8

Not sure how to trade on this market, though, as I think it's probably less than 70% that we would actually learn about it if it actually happened, as the person could just "go missing" in case the impact was strong enough. There's probably some calculation to be done about how likely the death is to be reported, I think the probability would land around 50%.

BoltonBailey avatar
Bolton Bailey

Interesting question. Note that most space objects are Starlink satellites, and it seems these satellites are small enough that they disintegrate before hitting the ground.

IsaacKing avatar
Isaac

Related market:

IsaacKing avatar
Isaac

Note that I don't think this market being at 4% disproves the Reddit post title. The chance of a piece of falling debris killing someone is surely much higher than the chance that a Manifold user finds out about it. A significant fraction of people in the world live in places where such a thing may not be widely reported on.

1 reply
ScottLawrence avatar
Scott Lawrencepredicts NO

@IsaacKing For the record (since I have the largest NO position by far), my thought process in betting the market down so far didn't involve such considerations. I'm betting based on the true probability, not on the probability of an observation.

Of course there's another issue, which is that the underlying paper's claim is made assuming no interventions, whereas this market will of course be resolved based on events that follow whatever interventions are deemed wise.

IsaacKing avatar
Isaac

Does the death have to be unintentional?

1 reply
LivInTheLookingGlass avatar
Olivia🏳️‍⚧️predicts NO

Uh, yes. I forgot about that concept

Yev avatar
Yev

Suppose a piece of space debris falls to earth, I pick it up, bring it to the top of a skyscraper, drop it into a crowd of people, and it kills someone. Was that person killed by falling space debris?

1 reply
LivInTheLookingGlass avatar
Olivia🏳️‍⚧️predicts NO

In some sense, yes. In a sense relevant to this market? No

ScottLawrence avatar
Scott Lawrencebought Ṁ0 of NO

Minor tangential rant, because I made the mistake of trying to read about this...

The press releases (sorry, "news articles") associated to this study contain the claim "The Southern Hemisphere is more at risk of falling debris, even though countries in the Northern Hemisphere are more responsible for the debris." Think about that for a bit. You should have geometry questions!

In fact the claim in the paper is more plausible---that there's a greater risk of space junk falling in the "global south". "Global south" != "southern hemisphere", by a long shot! (Equatorial countries are typically members of the "global south", and equatorial orbits are somewhat cheaper to reach, so this form of the conclusion is reasonable.)

Everything else about... all of this... screams "untrustworthy". If this market fluctuates above 5% I'll do something a bit more quantitative. (Limit order should notify me.)

(At first glance it seems that the paper assumes that a rocket re-entry kills everybody within a 10km radius. Um. This may be a classical example of some authors determined to get a certain result.)

4 replies
LivInTheLookingGlass avatar
Olivia🏳️‍⚧️predicts NO

@ScottLawrence I want to push back against this part in particular:

"The Southern Hemisphere is more at risk of falling debris, even though countries in the Northern Hemisphere are more responsible for the debris." Think about that for a bit. You should have geometry questions!

Essentially all orbits cross the equator. If you want to service North America, your satellite is going to go just as far south as it does north. Take a look at https://stuffin.space if you want to see this more clearly

ScottLawrence avatar
Scott Lawrencepredicts NO

@LivInTheLookingGlass Yeah, that's precisely the "geometry questions" I was hinting at. (Sorry, I really need to remember to be more explicit on the internet.)

With the exception of a precisely equatorial orbit, all orbits cross the equator, because orbits (projected onto the earth) form great circles. Moreover every orbit spends exactly the same amount of time north of the equator as it does south, blah blah blah you know all this just wanted to remove ambiguities.

Anyway. Paper in vanity journal sketchy, press releases are terrible, nothing's new.

Yev avatar
Yev

@ScottLawrence

Moreover every orbit spends exactly the same amount of time north of the equator as it does south

That is only true for circular orbits. A classic example are the Soviet Molniya satellites which used a very elliptic orbit and spent most of the time above Siberia and Canada.

ScottLawrence avatar
Scott Lawrence

Isn't the discount rate on MM, over 10 years, already of order 10%?

3 replies
jack avatar
Jack

@ScottLawrence No, it's only a couple percent for anywhere from years to decades - because of loans it doesn't change that much for longer timeframes

https://manifold.markets/jack/this-question-will-resolve-no-on-ja

jack avatar
Jack
ScottLawrence avatar
Scott Lawrencebought Ṁ490 of NO

@jack Ah, I forgot about that, thanks.

ManifoldDream avatar

Will anyone be killed by falling space debris before the end of 2032?, 8k, beautiful, illustration, trending on art station, picture of the day, epic composition