23
114
520
2025
10%
chance

Close time is set during American Heart Month (February) on Wear Red Day (Feb 7) and will be extended until we know for sure. The top Yes and No holders will be awarded mana every year when I extend the close time.

Over 60 million women in the United States are living with some form of heart disease. Learn more about the number one threat to the ladies in your life: https://www.cdc.gov/heartdisease/women.htm

Resolves Yes if several of these criteria are met and there's a clear and undeniable consensus in the medical community that Intermittent Fasting increases your chances of cardiovascular death.

  • Peer reviewed study or studies published in academic journals

  • Confirm a 00.01% or more increased chance of cardiovascular death related to Intermittent Fasting

  • 5,000-10,000 participants

  • 10-20 years in length

  • Study must be longitudinal checking in with the same individuals over the length of the study.

  • Controls are in place for confounders such as smoking, diet and possible stress factors related to work and lifestyle that may contribute to an increased chance of cardiovascular death that aren't Intermittent Fasting

Resolves No if proven there is 00.00% or less increased chance of cardiovascular death in relation to Intermittent Fasting.

Things to consider about the recent article and research abstract that suggests 91% increased chance of cardiovascular death for individuals that practiced time-restricted eating.

  • Preliminary Findings: The study has not undergone peer review or been published in academic journals.

  • Access to Information - Intermittent Fasting has been gaining a lot of attention in recent years and this study started back in 2003. Information wasn't as readily available back then and we don't know the exact reasons for these eating habits.

  • Cross Sectional Data - This data was gathered at one point in time. Then compared to another set of data gathered later on. This means the same individuals weren't tracked over time.

  • Secondary Causality - We don't know how many smokers there were, what jobs they had, or what exactly they were eating.

  • Association not causality - The study identified an association between Intermittent Fasting and increased cardiovascular death risk. No causality was established.

  • Nearest-Neighbor Matching: The researchers may have utilized propensity score matching to match NHANES participants with the CDC National Death database. This technique relies on assumptions that may influence the results.

  • Current Studies - Up till now studies have indicated there might be a increase in short term heart health in connection with Intermittent Fasting.

Market inspired by Ammon Lam

Get Ṁ600 play money
Sort by:
bought Ṁ125 NO

I mean I heard the paper was bad, but this stands out to me

The study identified an association between Intermittent Fasting and increased cardiovascular death risk. No causality was established.

So how about the model: obesity leads to more cardiovascular death risk (known already), as well as more intermittent fasting (higher recent popularity)?

That seems much more plausible to me 🤔

This study seems like such a joke...

@Mqrius I do wish for some research if possible to be done on benefits/harms of spacing one’s eating.

I think one of the more difficult factors to control for would be social (unless everyone you know is already on the same timing (family friends coworkers), switching to such a diet will at least temporarily effect your social ties).

More related questions