Will SpaceX’s 5th Starship test flight have a “rapid unscheduled disassembly“?
💎
Premium
28
Ṁ36k
resolved Oct 13
Resolved
NO
Booster RUD
Resolved
NO
Starship (upper stage) RUD

Resolves YES if the next (5th) Starship integrated flight test has an unplanned explosion or breakup, known as a "rapid unscheduled/unplanned disassembly (RUD)".

The upper stage and booster each resolve separately to whether they each have a RUD.

  • Being destroyed on contact with the surface as planned is not a RUD.

  • Other examples of things that aren't sufficient to count as a RUD: a part flying off without causing the breakup of the rocket, or a single engine having a fire.

  • Exploding on the pad before the launch would also count as a RUD.

  • We'll use a common sense definition here. The sources for resolution will be SpaceX, media, prominent space youtubers, etc. In case it isn't clear then I'll run a poll.

  • This question is about the next Starship mission with a planned trajectory that reaches space (100km altitude) - any low altitude test does not count for example. The close date is not a deadline, the question resolves when the flight occurs.

Get
Ṁ1,000
and
S3.00
Sort by:

It exploded on ground so it is nor a RUD

@DanielCsomor this is far from obvious. It will depend on a) did it explode? And b) was the explosion unintentional?

@JoshuaWilkes it was fully expected to blow up

@DanielCsomor yep

Being destroyed on contact with the surface as planned is not a RUD.

I guess I would have waited to see what SpaceX say about the ending of the flight.

Ie if we get a statement from statement from SpaceX saying that this was an RUD would you unresolve or would you say that the market conditions supercede what SpaceX says about this?

@JoshuaWilkes if it was "unplanned" then yes. But everything I heard on the stream indicated it was planned, unless I misunderstood.

@jack specifically, it was always planned to touch down in the water and there's no way for it to survive a water landing intact. Also they said they did not plan to recover the hardware.

@jack what I'm imagining is that we get a statement to the effect of "we didn't think it would explode like that as opposed to just sinking"

To be clear, I don't think this is very likely! But I think it's not impossible

@JoshuaWilkes I mean, we'll see what their post test report says and the market rules say what they say, we can cross that bridge if we get there.

@jack agreed

Where is the option for stage 0 RUD (The tower)

© Manifold Markets, Inc.Terms + Mana-only TermsPrivacyRules