Did Hans Niemann obtain a leak of Magnus Carlsen's prep?
19
18
320
resolved Oct 18
Resolved as
5%

What is the probability that Hans Niemann obtained a leak of Magnus Carlsen's prep prior to their September 4 chess game in the Sinquefield Cup? (Any means of obtaining a leak would count here.)

Background: https://www.nytimes.com/2022/09/13/crosswords/hans-niemann-magnus-carlsen-cheating-accusation.html

Resolution

If conclusive evidence emerges, resolves to YES if he did obtain a leak or NO if he did not. Otherwise, resolves to market probability at the time of close.

The market close time will be quasi-randomly extended if there is still ongoing trading activity; using a procedure similar to that described in https://manifold.markets/MartinRandall/is-the-sky-blue-resolves-to-mkt. The close time will be no earlier than 10/15 and no later than 10/30.

(The intent is if the market collectively decides for example 25% chance that he obtained a leak based on the available evidence, then this market should end up at about 25%.)

Related:


Close date updated to 2022-10-30 11:59 pm

Get Ṁ200 play money

🏅 Top traders

#NameTotal profit
1Ṁ31
2Ṁ28
3Ṁ27
4Ṁ19
5Ṁ10
Sort by:
predicted NO

No new trades in the past 2 days, market is now closed.

What are the base rates here? I can't recall any examples of this happening, but my knowledge of chess history is far from encyclopedic.

bought Ṁ15 of NO

The main advantage of this theory is that it explains the evidence well. But I am doubtful that this is a thing that happens.

@PeterBorah Great question. One I can think of is https://www.chessable.com/blog/fabiano-caruanas-prep-accidentally-uploaded-to-youtube/ (2018). There was also speculation on a Carlsen leak in 2021? And as another related category, in many esports I think news about team leaks come up every couple years - so it's uncommon but not unheard of. So I would guesstimate that an instance of a leak becoming publicly known probably happens once every few years?