Detailed Status of Hans Neimann in Chess by mid 2028
18
188
980
2028
52%
Still playing and no longer suspected
27%
Still playing - widely suspected of cheating
11%
Not playing - Has quit pro chess without being banned
3%
Other
1.6%
Banned for Cheating - physical implant
1.6%
Banned for Cheating - non internal helpers
1.6%
Still playing - revealed and proven to be honest in some way
1.6%
Not playing - Confessed but without explanation
1.6%
Banned for cheating - non-implant device

/Ernie/playing-retired-banned-chess-status

^^^ This is the high-level three true outcomes version

Resolution

Somewhat subjective but I'll try to poll experts, use ai/LLMs/etc to get a single fair main outcome.

Explanations

  • Cheat physical device: specific data on a real device like ear audio implant, magnetic implant, etc is found and he is also banned. Must be at least semipermanent, and be implanted inside his body.

  • Cheat non-implant is a thing that communicates by vibrations in his shoe, pocket, hair etc. Or deep hearing aide with onboard battery. The difference is it can be personally removed.

  • Cheat helper: someone or something was giving him info visually or his sound over the air in the playing hall for example a small light+polarized contact lenses, or a rhythmic cough plus exact clock for interpretation etc.

As of now, 12/2023, I'd say he is "Still playing - widely suspected of cheating"

Note: for the first few days will adjust options per bettor feedback

Get Ṁ200 play money
Sort by:
opened a Ṁ100 Still playing and no... YES at 50% order

I would say at this point he’s no longer actively “suspected of cheating”. It’s known that he cheated in computer chess when younger (he has admitted to such) but no one really thinks he cheated over the board against Carlsen, for instance.

He is being invited to large major tournaments (like the Tata Steel Challengers), Carlsen and Niemann settled, etc

I believe it's spelled "Niemann"

@BoltonBailey I tried to correct it, but I think it's a bit slow to update.. It should be "Hans Niemann" - I will check back in about 10mins to verify I haven't somehow made it worse by trying to fix it

@Gen yeah I fixed it too, around the same time. Local caching can get pretty strong on manifold nowadays

What games count? Over the board only? Does an admission count without method revealed (as can help others)

@firstuserhere generally it's based on if he's still playing in FIDE or other leading chess tournaments or banned. Admission without details would be "confessed and quit". Is it possible he confesses to more cheating, for example even in top live games, but still plays?