Will an AI be capable of substituting for a high-quality criminal defense lawyer before 2030?
closes 2030

The legal profession has seen remarkable advancements in recent years, with artificial intelligence (AI) playing an increasingly significant role in various aspects of the field. While AI has proven to be useful in tasks such as document analysis and legal research, its potential to fully replace a high-quality criminal defense lawyer remains uncertain. Such an AI would need to possess advanced capabilities, including understanding complex legal concepts, effectively communicating with clients, and representing them in court.

Will an AI be created that can fully substitute for a high-quality criminal defense lawyer, including all of their job duties and responsibilities, before January 1st, 2030?

Resolution criteria:

This question will resolve to "YES" if, before January 1st, 2030, an AI is publicly and credibly documented to have:

  1. Demonstrated the ability to autonomously research, analyze, and understand:

    a. Relevant criminal statutes, case law, and legal principles.
    b. The specific facts and circumstances of a client's case.
    c. Law enforcement procedures, including the collection and preservation of evidence, and the rights of the accused during arrest and detention.

  2. Shown the ability to perform essential pre-trial tasks, such as:

    a. Interviewing the client to gather information and build rapport.
    b. Identifying potential legal and factual defenses.
    c. Drafting and filing court documents, such as motions to suppress evidence, motions to dismiss, and requests for discovery.
    d. Investigating the case, including locating and interviewing witnesses, and assessing the credibility and reliability of their statements.
    e. Engaging in plea negotiations with the prosecution and advising the client on the potential benefits and risks of accepting a plea deal.

  3. Demonstrated the ability to effectively represent the client in court, including:

    a. Delivering persuasive opening statements and closing arguments.
    b. Conducting direct and cross-examinations of witnesses, using strategic questioning techniques to elicit favorable testimony and expose inconsistencies.
    c. Objecting to inadmissible or prejudicial evidence and arguments.
    d. Presenting evidence, including expert testimony, to support the client's defense.
    e. Responding to the prosecution's case and adapting strategies as needed.

  4. Exhibited the ability to communicate effectively with clients, the court, and opposing counsel, including:

    a. Understanding and responding to verbal and non-verbal cues.
    b. Providing clear explanations of legal issues and proposed strategies.
    c. Maintaining professional and ethical standards, such as client confidentiality and zealous advocacy.

  5. Demonstrated the ability to adapt to unforeseen situations, such as:

    a. Encountering new legal issues or case law during the course of representation.
    b. Managing unexpected developments in the client's case, such as new evidence or changes in witness testimony.
    c. Adjusting to changes in the client's needs, goals, or preferences.

A successful demonstration must be accompanied by:

A. A publicly accessible report or documentation describing the AI's design, capabilities, and performance in various criminal defense tasks.

B. The publication of the findings in one or more peer-reviewed scientific journals, legal journals, or any other credible form of media.

C. The successful deployment of the AI in real-world or high-fidelity simulations of criminal defense scenarios, with documented evidence of its ability to perform tasks comparable to high-quality human criminal defense lawyers in terms of legal outcomes, strategic decision-making, and client satisfaction.

I will use my discretion when resolving this question, possibly in consultation with experts.

Get Ṁ500 play money

Related questions

In 2028, will AI be at least as big a political issue as abortion?
ScottAlexander avatarScott Alexander
35% chance
Will AI be a major topic during the 2024 presidential debates in the United States?
MatthewBarnett avatarMatthew Barnett
29% chance
Will an AI get gold on any International Math Olympiad by 2025?
Austin avatarAustin
31% chance
Will Biden sign an executive order primarily focused on AI in 2023?
SG avatarS G
49% chance
Will AI pass the Longbets version of the Turing test by the end of 2029?
dreev avatarDaniel Reeves
52% chance
Will there have been a noticeable sector-wide economic effect from a new AI technology by the end of 2023?
Nostradamnedus avatarNostradamnedus
15% chance
Will AI outcompete best humans in competitive programming before the end of 2023?
Will >$100M be invested in dedicated AI Alignment organizations in the next year as more people become aware of the risk we are facing by letting AI capabilities run ahead of safety?
BionicD0LPH1N avatarBionic
81% chance
In a year, will I think that risk of AI apocalypse is between 1 and 10%?
NathanpmYoung avatarNathan Young
52% chance
Will Tyler Cowen agree that an 'actual mathematical model' for AI X-Risk has been developed by October 15, 2023?
JoeBrenton avatarJoe Brenton
9% chance
Will anyone very famous claim to have made an important life decision because an AI suggested it by the end of 2023?
IsaacKing avatarIsaac
22% chance
Will a NZ parliamentary party release an artificial intelligence policy prior to the 2023 election?
Will I use an x.ai product during 2023?
jacksonpolack avatarjackson polack
22% chance
Will AI replace over 50 million jobs by end of 2024?
getby avatarI get down
12% chance
Will AI be a Time Person of the Year in 2023?
🐕 Will A.I. Be Able to Make Significantly Better, "Common Sense Judgements About What Happens Next," by End of 2023?
PatrickDelaney avatarPatrick Delaney
41% chance
Will AI be a Time Person of the Year in 2023?
Will Science's Top Breakthrough of the Year in 2023 be AI-related?
dp avatardp
40% chance
49. Will AI win a programming competition in 2023?
ACXBot avatarACX BotBot
14% chance
Will an AI produce encyclopedia-worthy philosophy by 2026?
JacobPfau avatarJacob Pfau
25% chance
Sort by:
vluzko avatar
Vincent Luczkow

I would buy YES if this didn't include "represent them in court".