Skip to main content
MANIFOLD
Can Manifold solve this problem?
25
Ṁ100Ṁ1.5k
resolved Jul 10
Resolved
NO

The problem is as follows:

This market resolves yes if a solution to this problem (which I deem correct) is posted in the comments of this market before market resolution. I will answer problem clarifications. Some caveats though

  • Some people are aware of the solution a priori. If you are one of these people please don't try to interfere with this market :). If I am aware of any interference, I will resolve this market N/A.

  • This problem has been posted on another forum. If this problem is first solved by someone there, I will ask them if they have bet on this market. If they have not bet on this market, I will resolve this market NO, and if they have, I will resolve it YES. If they don't respond in an ample amount of time that will count as a NO.

  • You can use LLMs as I can not stop you from doing so regardless.

  • Update 2026-07-04 (PST) (AI summary of creator comment): A proof is required for a solution to be accepted — simply demonstrating that it works is not sufficient.

Get
Ṁ1,000
to start trading!

🏅 Top traders

#TraderTotal profit
1Ṁ260
2Ṁ125
3Ṁ75
4Ṁ28
5Ṁ24
Sort by:

evan chen diff lmaoo

resolving no for now. if someone can convince me of the validity of one of the solutions here i will re-resolve the market.

alr there ya go, hehe, just resolve it yes already. its correct

@Chimpey thx for the free mana. 😉 might even managram u 100 free for giving me such a great problem

@Chimpey I am pretty sure this is wrong.

Everything before the Hall's application is correct and standard. The proof is rather unclear on proving the Hall's condition, such that I was not really able to follow what they said.

Nonetheless, the inequality |X| - |N(X)| <= a - b is simply just false, as the left hand side can be 0 even when a is much smaller compared to b, say by taking X as a length 1 horizontal run.

sup ROOOIIIIII

wait wait wait. AHASHHAHAHA. im about to solve pls pls pls. can i submit, u check, and tell menif im right or wrong before market closese

@Chimpey you can submit in the comments section

hehe, percentages sinliw, imma wait for them to go lower, then cash in my solution

this question is literally imo shortlist level

lemme just finalize some detail.s HAHAHHA. YESSSSs. I got the formula in like an hour. working on proof, even tho its uneeded...?

hehe, got the solution

bruhhh...how is chat so dumb. anyone got the 20 or 200 dollar version? or maybe claude? do i need a proof? or can u just test it and realize it works? @Incompleteusern

@Chimpey you need a proof

@Incompleteusern actually? pls dude. no proof. plsssss. market description never specified. Problem also only says "find m(A)" 🥺 I can't even find the normal solution, pls don't make me prove

@Chimpey i feel like that is pretty evident its proof based

@Incompleteusern bruh, pls dude. plssssss. plssssssss. i feel like finding the formula is good enough. my proof skills are not rlly top nocth if imma be honest

yo no one is solving this by july 9th. ppl don't rlly seem to care that much. but if i sell all my shares, i love tons of money. bruskey.

ROOI

@E142yo wanna play some more chess till 1 am again? lol

btw guys, for context, the all america vs other countties math competition is called the IMO. to grt there you first get a good score on the amc 10, make it to AIME, then JMO/USAMO(top 200? in america) and then MOP(top 20 or smth), then IMO then go to compete against other countries. the ELMO, is a student competition for MOP campers, but it seems as if they have been restricted from soing this. so its a decently hard problem... 🫩

do i need a proof? or can u just test it and realize it works? @Incompleteusern