Which upcoming 2026 superhero/comic book movie wins the triple crown: fans, critics, cash?

This market ranks the highly anticipated superhero and comic book movies by a composite score made up of three components:

∙ Letterboxd rating (average user rating as of January 1, 2027)

∙ Metacritic score (critic score as of January 1, 2027)

∙ Domestic box office gross (total U.S. earnings as of January 1, 2027)

Each film will be ranked 1 through total # in each of the three categories. The #1 film in each category gets total number of films points, #2 gets total-1 points, and so on. The film with the highest total score across all categories will be selected as the winner. In case of a tie, Letterboxd rating will serve as the tiebreaker, followed by Metacritic, then box office.

Any film added must be based on a comic book or feature a costumed superhero as the central protagonist.

All data will be publicly available on Letterboxd, Metacritic, and Box Office Mojo.