Will the Russian moon lander suffer a catastrophic failure?
142
1.1K
1.9K
resolved Aug 20
Resolved
YES

Resolves YES if the lander fails before achieving its objective. Landing scheduled for 8/21 currently.

Get Ṁ200 play money

🏅 Top traders

#NameTotal profit
1Ṁ1,497
2Ṁ403
3Ṁ178
4Ṁ167
5Ṁ139
Sort by:
bought Ṁ145 of YES

Now for India 👀

bought Ṁ172 of YES

Resolves Yes based on Roscosmos statement

predicted YES

@uair01 some say it is crashed already );

F

predicted YES

@ICRainbow I haven't seen any further info besides the initial statement by roscosmos, just articles quoting that one statement. But tbh it's not looking hopeful 😬

bought Ṁ300 of YES

F

What is the objective it is meant to achieve?

predicted YES

@CorySchneider good question. It has a dozen vaguely defined objectives, and I wonder which one this market's owner has in mind.

predicted NO

@CorySchneider The objective is landing and transmitting back to earth. Catastrophic implies crash, no?

@BTE Catastrophic failure doesn’t necessarily imply a crash, but my main thought is that the title and the body imply two different (sets of) conditions. It could land without catastrophic failure, yet fail to “achieve its objectives”.

predicted NO

@CorySchneider I see. My intent was to resolve this market YES if the lander fails to communicate that it has landed safely. I never even looked at the post landing objectives, so bad choice of words in the description on my part, sorry about that.

@BTE No worries. I’m new around here and just getting a feel for how rigorous the resolution criteria tend to be. Not trying to bust your balls.

I hope they stick the landing!

predicted NO

@CorySchneider No worries! And welcome!! Feel free to bust my balls anytime LOL!!

predicted NO

For reference, the head of Russia's space agency's estimate of failure was 30%.

bought Ṁ3 of NO

@ShadowyZephyr interesting.. source?

predicted NO

https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-023-02536-2

"In June, Yuri Borisov, head of Russia’s space agency Roscosmos, described the Luna 25 mission as “high risk”, with a 70% chance of success."

predicted YES

@ShadowyZephyr funny that their presently stated 70% success rate contradicts their earlier statements about maximum allowed failure rate:

On 2023 June 13th, in an interview for TASS, representatives of Lavochkin Research and Production Association ("НПО имени Лавочкина") said: "In accordance with the Terms of Reference, the probability of mission success must be at least 80%.”
Source.