This is mostly a duplicate of Isaac's market, created because they requested a copy by an impartial, trustworthy 3rd party.
Resolution criteria
This only counts Manifold deciding to take it away from Isaac personally. It does not count Manifold choosing to remove the "Trustworthy. Ish." badge from all traders, or reword the general criteria that badge-holders must meet, nor a bug that makes it not display on their profile, or anything like that.
If Isaac asks Manifold to take away the badge, that also does not count. It must be Manifold's descision.
If Isaac is banned from Manifold, that also resolves as YES.
If the badge is removed and reinstated later, that counts as YES, as long as the removal was intentional. It still counts even if they decide it was a mistake in retrospect, as long as it was intentional at the time of the removal.
Context:
See discussion on Isaac's own market: