Who will Destiny debate at Manifest?
70
3.6kṀ33k
resolved Sep 24
100%98.5%
Eliezer Yudkowsky
0.5%
Robin Hanson
0.1%
Nate Silver
0.2%
Aella
0.1%
No one
0.0%
Richard Hanania
0.0%
Obamna
0.0%
Emmet Shear
0.0%
Rob Miles
0.2%
Vaush
0.3%Other

Destiny has agreed to debate with whoever we want him to at Manifest. But now we need to figure out who he should debate, and what topic.

I will resolve this once we have something officially scheduled (probably in around 1 week at the latest hopefully). If we have something officially scheduled and it gets cancelled last minute for weird reasons then unlucky.

If it turns into more of a discussion rather than I debate I will still count it.

Comment Bounty

If you happen to suggest the topic and person he ends up debating in the comments I'll managram you M$1000 (if you do want to post a bunch of suggestions please keep it within one comment/in the replies of one thread of comments and less than 20 guesses).

Get
Ṁ1,000
to start trading!

🏅 Top traders

#NameTotal profit
1Ṁ1,602
2Ṁ1,226
3Ṁ1,149
4Ṁ427
5Ṁ388
Sort by:

Is the "new percentage" function broken on multiple option markets? Or would buying 800 of anyone flip things (even though there appears to be >10000 on Yudkowsky)?

E.g.

If people have topic suggestions for Eliezer vs Destiny let me know!

Or if you are familiar with more of the nuance between some of their views and want to write a summary, I can even forward it to them which could be helpful.

@SirSalty Sorry if this isn’t the place, but: I’d recommend AI risk, even though Destiny hasn’t talked about it much. Destiny has been fairly dismissive about it in the past, and I think this is an area it would be worth changing his mind on. Eliezer would presumably agree. But Destiny would need to know that prompt in advance and given incentive to prepare; if he doesn’t have a strong position on it beforehand he’s unlikely to leave with one.

@CuylerBrehaut ai risk would be boring imo. destiny is really really not versed in it.

Be ye noticed that I did an insider trading

extending close date as we still haven't finalised it

@DavidChee Hopefully "haven't finalised it" means that it's close to being finalised!

Just in case it's not, I have made a post on the Destiny subreddit. Someone might have a good last-minute idea that hasn't come up yet, if not for a person, for topics

@DavidChee There are now a few ideas there, if needed, worth looking when you get a chance.

I've just sent this email to Robin Hanson:

@DavidChee did he reply?

IMO Aella and he would vibe best, they've had good conversations on stream before and both can enjoy really really weird conversations.

Rather than one topic, one could give them a moderator with a list of some of the more popular markets in the site and then ask them to make bets in each as they discuss/debate.

Actually, thinking about it more I figure that Destiny and Robin Hanson could have quite a rousing debate on Futarchy.

Robin invented the concept, and I think if he could take the side of defending its merits then Destiny would have a fun time arguing against it.

Hanson's Futarchy Manifesto here would be a solid basis for debate, if he still endorses any amount of it.

@Joshua What about both of them individually or all three together? 😂

@Joshua Destiny can talk to Aella any old time, I'd much rather see him talk to someone who's not already in his orbit.

© Manifold Markets, Inc.Terms + Mana-only TermsPrivacyRules