Will resolve based on consensus of qualified news sources and press releases from NASA that extraterrestrial life exists.
Update 2025-06-08 (PST) (AI summary of creator comment): - The confirmed extraterrestrial life must not have originated from Earth.
People are also trading
@Balasar I'm imagining a scenario where an RFK-type comes in and fires all the actual scientists or something like that.
@OwenChen What about a case where the detected life is related but the origin isn't clear?
One possibility is that life started here but spread elsewhere (e.g. Earth has life, meteor impacts Earth, debris lands on Mars, Mars has living/fossil life) but the opposite could also be true (i.e. Mars seeded Earth).
Another possibility is that we may find life that's remarkably similar to our own but for which its ancestry is unclear. Convergent evolution may result in fossils which LOOK like ancient Earth microbes but without any genetic material to verify that.