Will Helion achieve breakeven deuterium-tritium fusion before 2024?
75
344
1.3K
resolved Jan 1
Resolved
NO

From https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/open-thread-232: "Speaking of turning money into big positive impacts on the future, Sam Altman writes in to say he enjoyed the recent book review of The Future Of Fusion Energy, and that he predicts Helion (the fusion startup he’s a leading investor in) has a 85% chance of Q > 1 D-T fusion by 2024, and a 65% chance of Q > 1 D-He3 fusion by 2026."

Apr 14, 12:53pm: Will Helion achieve breakeven deuterium-tritium fusion by 2024? → Will Helion achieve breakeven deuterium-tritium fusion before 2024?

Get Ṁ200 play money

🏅 Top traders

#NameTotal profit
1Ṁ586
2Ṁ274
3Ṁ181
4Ṁ163
5Ṁ157
Sort by:
bought Ṁ10 of NO

They have finished operations with Trenta, and Polaris won't be assembled until January 2024, so there is no way they can achieve any breakeven BEFORE 2024.

predicted NO

related market:

bought Ṁ100 of NO
predicted NO

Doing D-D fusion and claiming D-T extrapolated breakeven doesn't count, right?

In order to lower costs, many experimental machines are designed to run on test fuels of hydrogen or deuterium alone, leaving out the tritium. In this case, the term extrapolated breakeven is used to define the expected performance of the machine running on D-T fuel based on the performance when running on hydrogen or deuterium alone.

The records for extrapolated breakeven are slightly higher than the records for scientific breakeven. Both JET and JT-60 have reached values around 1.25 (see below for details) while running on D-D fuel. When running on D-T, only possible in JET, the maximum performance is about half the extrapolated value.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fusion_energy_gain_factor

predicted NO

I don't understand why Sam Altman mentioned DT fusion. Helion is focused on DHe3 fusion, right? Do their machines have enough neutron sheilding?

bought Ṁ10 of NO

Given the quote, I assume break-even is Q > 1, not Q > 5.

@LucaMasters Correct.

"Will Helion achieve breakeven deuterium-tritium fusion by 2024?"

Will Helion achieve breakeven deuterium-tritium fusion by 2024?
predicted NO
Hmmm, to be honest I should've inquired which breakeven point was meant before betting (I was expecting something higher than Q > 1 tbh) but I'll stand by my bet I suppose.
Good to see someone is putting these predictions to the test!

More related questions