Resolution Criteria
Collective Intelligence (ANY of these):
Platform predicts major events through emergent patterns before traditional methods (like Asimov's Multivac)
Mathematical or scientific breakthrough emerges from seemingly unrelated posts with no single author
New symbolic language evolves within hours across the platform (like in Ted Chiang's "Story of Your Life")
Documented cases of "X-time" where users globally report altered time perception (like "fleet time" in Vinge's "A Fire Upon the Deep")
Platform Self-Awareness (ANY of these):
Trending topics emerge with no individual user origin
Platform develops self-organizing "meta-hashtags"
Quantum-like conversation threads that exist in multiple states until engaged (like in Greg Egan's "Quarantine")
Platform begins mediating user conflicts autonomously
Duality Integration (ANY of these):
"Unity cascades" where opposing groups spontaneously adopt each other's language
Posts consistently read differently by different groups while both readings remain valid
Emergence of "quantum discourse states" holding opposing views simultaneously
Documented synthesis of major opposing ideological positions into novel perspectives
Scientific Validation (ANY of these):
3+ peer-reviewed papers in top journals documenting collective consciousness phenomena
Lab evidence of global brainwave synchronization correlating with platform activity
Research showing platform activity matches neural emergence models
Verified predictions through "collective premonition" events
Mass Experience (ANY of these):
100,000+ users report shared "collective dreaming" with verifiable common elements
Widespread documentation of "digital synaesthesia" across platform
Users demonstrate ability to access collective knowledge without searching
"Temporal echo" events where posts respond to future occurrences
Evidence Requirements
Each criterion requires verification by 3+ independent observers/experts
Must be documented through multiple methods (data logs, user reports, external measurements)
Phenomena must persist for 14+ days
Cannot be explained by AI, bots, or hidden platform features
Trading Tips
Watch for early signs like:
Unexplained mass behavior synchronization
Novel linguistic patterns emerging too fast for normal spread
Reports of shared experiences during major events
Factor in platform changes that could affect emergence
Monitor academic research and user reports for early signals
Platform begins mediating user conflicts autonomously
What would this look like?