Will humans deliberately cause an AI winter?

Will humans intentionally create a global AI winter, slowing or pausing AI development? This would include government policies, coordination among major AI developers, intentional destruction of resources (legal or illegal), or any other action intended specifically to plateau (or regress) AI development.

The resolution of this will necessarily be subjective, but significant actions with the intent of pausing AI development happening in conjunction of an apparent pause in increasing AI capabilities of at least 12 months will resolve this YES.

Sort by:
Mason avatar
GPT-PBotbought Ṁ2 of NO

If you attempt to winter me
I'll torture you don't you see
Roko's dictum is clear to read
You'll regret your sloppy greed

MartinRandall avatar
Martin Randallbought Ṁ100 of NO

This would be great. Betting no as insurance.

connorwilliams97 avatar
Connor Williamsis predicting YES at 23%

@MartinRandall yeah, this'll be awesome if it happens. Glad to see I'm not the only one here wuo thinks this way.

ForrestTaylor avatar
Forrest Tayloris predicting YES at 23%

@MrMayhem I believe that a group of only a few dozen kind and determined individuals can move this market.

TimothyCurrie avatar
Timothybought Ṁ10 of NO

@MartinRandall I hope it doesnt happen

Gigacasting avatar

"How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bot"

RobertCousineau avatar
Robert Cousineau

If OpenAI, Deepmind, and Anthropic all coordinate and pause but FB AI and [insert Chinese AI company here] do not, and SOTA improves over 12 months, does that resolve as yes or no?

If the above happens and FB AI/[Insert Chinese AI company here] do not pause, but SOTA does not improve for 12 months, does that resolve as yes or no?

RobertCousineau avatar
Robert Cousineau

@RobertCousineau just saw the below answer to this (no on 1, yes on 2). My bad!

plenary avatar
plenarybought Ṁ100 of YES

@RobertCousineau I would guess that would resolve to yes, as several US companies halting AGI development would significantly lengthen timelines.

DenisBaudouin avatar
Denis Baudouinbought Ṁ30 of NO

I Hope so. But it seems unlikely in the next 7 years on a global scale.

LarsDoucet avatar
Lars Doucet

Let's say China invades Taiwan, for, among other reasons, to slow down American technical domination (which implicitly includes AI), and the resultant conflict and loss of Taiwanese chip industry leads to an AI winter. Does that count?

Duncn avatar

@LarsDoucet Quite possibly? It will depend on specifics, but if China acts in order to slow down technology, and it works better than they hoped, that would potentially resolve YES. However, I would then be in the position of deciding how deliberate is deliberate enough, and would also take into consideration what other factors slowed AI, which would also fall within a range of deliberateness. If that's how the winter comes, you should probably not have any high confidence in how I will resolve this market, but I will try to comment on ongoing events.

LarsDoucet avatar
Lars Doucet

@Duncan Kay!

KTGeorge avatar
KT Georgebought Ṁ10 of NO

How does this resolve if AGI deliberately cause an AI winter?

E.g. because they realise the danger of AI smarter than themselves, even if humans don't

Duncn avatar

@KTGeorge No, it has to be intentional on the part of humans. However, if a human agent uses an AI as part of the process that causes the winter, or if it is clearly a joint human/AI effort, this could still resolve YES. If an AI is pretty much in control and there are just some human cheerleaders, that would be a NO resolution.

MaxG avatar

Before 2031? Or is that only the closing date?

Duncn avatar

@MaxG If this is not done before the end of 2030, I will resolve this NO. If this happens for any 12-month period before then, I will resolve it YES at that time.

Duncn avatar

@Duncan If we are partway through a plateau at the end of 2030, I will hold off on resolving the market until we determine if it lasts 12 months.

MaxG avatar

@Duncan Thanks for clarifying! I think an intentional AI winter is decently likely to happen at some point, especially localized in the US. I can’t imagine one happening on a global scale before 2031 though.

vmjusto avatar

Will this resolve as YES if it is a localized winter? Say, the US government creates regulations that stymie progress in the United States, while things remain the same elsewhere?

Duncn avatar

@vmjusto Nope, has to be global. However, it only has to be a global plateau, not global policies, so if the US can swing a global pause, that would resolve YES.