Will Manifold add the ability to exclude non-predictive markets from calibration in 2023?
24
410
αΉ€470
resolved Dec 31
Resolved
NO

Adding the possibility to create separate calibration charts with custom inclusion criteria also counts.

Get αΉ€200 play money

πŸ… Top traders

#NameTotal profit
1αΉ€156
2αΉ€121
3αΉ€82
4αΉ€65
5αΉ€54
Sort by:

I support the option being available, but I think it's likely bad practice for an individual to use it. If you're consistently failing to predict the outcomes of self-referential markets, that does meaningfully reflect on your general forecasting ability. Self-referential markets often put some users against each other, which leads them to be strongly anti-inductive, which is why they're hard to predict; but many things in real life are also anti-inductive in the same way! (e.g. the stock market.) It just happens at a larger scale, so the actions of a single individual have a harder time influencing the outcome.

predicted NO

@IsaacKing IMO predicting real life events and playing self-referential social games are significantly different skills, and even assuming they're closely related the magintude of profits mean participation in the latter makes them dominate calibration. Roughly half of my profit comes from two markets: 1. realizing you miscalculated incentives 2. spotting a profit transfer in progress and placing a limit order.

This is a good idea!

This should be pretty easy with the new nonpredictive group, it is coupled to a parameter on the markets themselves

bought αΉ€10 of NO

@ian in general filtering by group would work nicely, everybody could just make their own "markets I want to ignore" group based on what they find useful