[Metaculus] Will Iran carry out a deadly attack within Israel before September 1, 2024? (5 or more deaths in 24 hours)
➕
Plus
54
Ṁ140k
resolved Sep 2
Resolved
NO

Will Iran carry out a deadly attack within Israel before September 1, 2024?

Resolves the same as the original on Metaculus.


Resolution criteria

This question resolves Yes if, following the date of this question's publication and before September 1, 2024, credible reports indicate that an attack attributed to Iran and occurring within Israel's borders has led to the death of at least five individuals.

Fine print and additional background information can be found on Metaculus.


Once the original resolves, its resolution will be applied to this market automatically. Trustworthy-ish users are encouraged to resolve this market before then if the outcome is known and unambiguous. Feel free to ping @jskf to request early resolution or to report issues.

Get
Ṁ1,000
and
S3.00
Sort by:

@jskf This can resolve NO, thank you!

bought Ṁ100 YES

This is still relatively unlikely, but Israel’s preemptive attack on Hezbollah and Hezbollah’s announced commencement of its retaliation from before, the likelihood has increased for some direct attack by Iran on Israel in the coming days.

https://x.com/sentdefender/status/1827547154665103528

opened a Ṁ50,000 NO at 1.0% order

@nsokolsky limit is up

Why's this so low? Sept 1st is drawing close, but it would surprise nobody if the ceasefire deal fell through, right? and there's still 10 days to go. I feel the fair value of this market is more like 15%.

Iran doesn't have a good track record of successful rocket strikes against Israel. Israel has the best missile defense system in the world. Their April strike injured 31 people but thankfully didn't kill anyone.

bought Ṁ50 YES

Ya, that's well evidenced, but the injuries caused in April suggest that P(deaths|attack) is not trivial still (e.g. 30%+)

I now believe the fair value of the market is much lower (e.g. 2%) but that's more because of the news developments re: Iran further delaying retaliation.

Agreed - good risk:reward buying some Yes shares here, 1% is overconfident. Israel could still carry out further strikes against the IRGC (for example) which could expedite Iranian strikes on Israeli territory.

I agree that an Iranian attack will be thwarted by Israel, but probability of a "Yes" resolution will increase if one commences.

Why is this so much lower than https://manifold.markets/PoliticalEconomyPK/will-iran-attack-israel-in-the-next?r=ZDRoaW5lcw

Is it because an Iranian attack is expected not to be deadly?

You should read the criteria on Metaculus carefully!

opened a Ṁ11,000 NO at 5% order

Iran's long-distance missiles are absolute trash compared to Israel's air defense system. They're not going to be able to kill anyone in Israel. And if they do, it's likely that Israel will wreak absolute havoc within their borders, similar to what they did in Yemen recently.

bought Ṁ250 NO

The details on Metaculus specify that there need to be five fatalities within 24 hours.

I think Iran will attack, but I don't expect them to be any more successful than in April.

© Manifold Markets, Inc.Terms + Mana-only TermsPrivacyRules