Should artists be compensated for their work if it is used to train AI systems capable of replicating their style? | Manifold

Should artists be compensated for their work if it is used to train AI systems capable of replicating their style?

56

Never closes

Always compensate artists for AI training use

No compensation if artwork is public.

Compensate only if AI imitates the style.

Results / other

Inspired from Gary Marcus tweets.

Follow up:

AI Copyright Law

Get

1,000

to start trading!

People are also trading

Will OpenAI pay compensation to people who their AIs "defame"?

Will AI be able to create art in a "human-like way" within Photoshop, GIMP, or Paint.NET by the end of 2025?

Will AI-generated art win a major, traditionally human-only art competition by 2030?

By 2030, will AI be able to produce a song that is indistinguishable from a new song by a particular artist?

Will an artificial intelligence create a work of art of its own volition before 2050?

Will a work created by AI have been judged as an infinging work by 2030, in the US Court system.

Will there be a test-time scaling overhang for AI aesthetics?

Will the widespread blacklisting of AI art be sustained to 2028?

Sort by:

How is it regulated now? Is copying style without consent against copyright?

@MrLuke255 Merely mimicking somebody's style doesn't violate US copyright law. Mimicking somebody's style might affect a trademark case, but the case would need to be based on something more solid to start with (like using someone's trademark in a way that confuses consumers).

Of course new laws could be passed.

Interesting that there is no "No, never" option. I assume that falls under "Results / other"?

@AndrewBrown heist/hacking aside, I'm unsure how you could use private artwork without consent?

@PaulBenjaminPhotographer Imagine if Google used unlisted YouTube videos for training.

People are also trading

Will OpenAI pay compensation to people who their AIs "defame"?

Will AI be able to create art in a "human-like way" within Photoshop, GIMP, or Paint.NET by the end of 2025?

Will AI-generated art win a major, traditionally human-only art competition by 2030?

By 2030, will AI be able to produce a song that is indistinguishable from a new song by a particular artist?

Will an artificial intelligence create a work of art of its own volition before 2050?

Will a work created by AI have been judged as an infinging work by 2030, in the US Court system.

Will there be a test-time scaling overhang for AI aesthetics?

Will the widespread blacklisting of AI art be sustained to 2028?

Related questions

Will OpenAI pay compensation to people who their AIs "defame"?

Will AI be able to create art in a "human-like way" within Photoshop, GIMP, or Paint.NET by the end of 2025?

Will AI-generated art win a major, traditionally human-only art competition by 2030?

By 2030, will AI be able to produce a song that is indistinguishable from a new song by a particular artist?

Will an artificial intelligence create a work of art of its own volition before 2050?

Will a work created by AI have been judged as an infinging work by 2030, in the US Court system.

Will there be a test-time scaling overhang for AI aesthetics?

Will the widespread blacklisting of AI art be sustained to 2028?

© Manifold Markets, Inc.•Terms•Privacy