What percentage of people who undergo laser-eye surgery view it as a major negative turning point in their life?
6
340Ṁ58resolved Jul 13
1H
6H
1D
1W
1M
ALL
65%44%
0.1%
35%1.7%
0.3%
40%Other
14%
<2% because the LASIK Quality of Life Collaboration Project quizzed 216 people and 4 of them were "Very
dissatisfied" or worse after 6 months had passed since surgery. Source: https://cdn.jamanetwork.com/ama/content_public/journal/ophth/935
Inspired by https://manifold.markets/SneakySly/will-i-get-lasik-by-the-end-of-the
How to participate in this market:
- Leave a response with your estimated probability and an argument for why it's the correct probability.
- I'll resolve the market to the the most compelling argument.
By "major negative turning point", I mean something more significant than "Yeah I wish I hadn't done the surgery, I see some halos at night now" and more like "I'm blind / I have huge amounts of eye pain on an ongoing basis / my vision is extremely blurry and I can't do my normal activities / etc"
Jul 12, 8:49pm: Ended up resolving to two answers (one 65% and the other 35%), because I found each of the arguments compelling. Interestingly, they were both pretty different *types* of arguments, and I found both lines of thinking helpful. Thanks Jack for the share of study analyses and your thinking and thanks Charlie for sharing your thinking!
This question is managed and resolved by Manifold.
Get 
1,000 to start trading!
1,000🏅 Top traders
| # | Name | Total profit |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Ṁ17 | |
| 2 | Ṁ8 |
Sort by:
Note, this is trying to estimate the rate of symptoms lasting e.g. 5 years. Not just 6 months, which unfortunately is what many of the studies are limited to.
Some more numbers to help clarify what levels of severity we're talking about: In this paper "Patient-reported outcomes 5 years after laser in situ keratomileusis" 0.3% of patients report having a lot of difficulty with daily activities because of vision, and 0.1% report never trying to do daily activities because of vision. 5% report having a lot of difficulty reading ordinary newspaper print. 0.8% report dry eyes "all the time" and 3.7% "most of the time"; 0.0% painful/sore eyes "all the time" and 0.7% "some of the time". (Though may be worth noting this study was funded by lasik manufacturers.)
@jack requested access to the google doc! (Maybe you meant for it to be public?) Thanks for sharing this!
I did a bit of literature review on this topic a few years ago. The studies I could find were very unsatisfactory, but I guesstimated that long-lasting "moderate" complications were probably around 0.1% - 1% rate, and I guesstimated that long-lasting severe complications are probably around 0.1% (although I don't have a very clear definition of what those severity buckets mean). My links and notes are at https://docs.google.com/document/d/1mTZSt7CGSO9g-4IMG2B8TGzBG0uTFvPI6BYOfyM9u8M/edit#
@TedSuzman Haha unfortunately it was just that 1/100 felt like too many and 1/1000 felt like too few.. I know one person who had problems afterward, but it was done many years ago and those problems didn't qualify as major according to your criteria.
@Charlie Would love to know your thinking behind this! If you add an explanation, your answer can potentially qualify to win