When will Trump overtake Harris in Nate Silver's Presidential forecast?
Basic
157
60k
resolved Aug 29
100%99.8%
August
0.1%
September
0.1%
October
0.0%
November
0.1%
He will not overtake her before polling day

Nate Silver has left 538 but he continues to maintain his Presidential election model which attempts to put a figure on how likely each of the candidates are to win the electoral college and therefore win the election.

After weeks when Trump was leading Biden by a wide margin, the model now shows Harris as a very slight favourite to win the election.

As of the afternoon of Tuesday 6th August, this model gives Harris a 53% chance of winning with Donald Trump on 46% (the missing 1% is due to rounding and the chance of a tied electoral college rather than a suggestion that RFK Jr has a 1% chance).

Will Donald Trump regain the lead in Nate Silver's model? If so, in which month will he first regain the lead?

Resolution notes:

  • The primary source of truth for this market is Nate Silver's blog. Some of his content is subscriber-only, but the results of the model can usually be found in other media outlets including Nate Silver's own Twitter feed.

  • This market only references Silver's model for winning the electoral collage (ie. winning the election) rather than winning the popular vote or getting ahead in the polling average

  • If Nate Silver stops publishing a Harris vs Trump model for any reason (including one of the candidates withdrawing) before Trump has overtaken Harris and does not bring it back online by the time of the election, this market will resolve to the "he will not overtake her" option.

Get Ṁ1,000 play money

🏅 Top traders

#NameTotal profit
1Ṁ4,599
2Ṁ2,010
3Ṁ1,367
4Ṁ1,275
5Ṁ1,079
Sort by:

Where did you see the model outputs?

@DavidShamespuyz The model is at this page:

https://www.natesilver.net/p/nate-silver-2024-president-election-polls-model

If you are not a subscriber, you can also see that the text at the top of the page is currently describing the fact that Trump has very narrowly passed Harris!

@traders

Off the back of some strong polling in Pennsylvania, Trump has overtaken Harris! This resolves to August.

Will he overtake her in the 538 forecast as well? Will he maintain the lead for a week?

/SimonGrayson/when-will-trump-overtake-harris-in-tq3ucuxus2

/SimonGrayson/will-harris-overtake-trump-in-nate

I thought this was fairly likely but there wasn't much liquidity. I should have left limit orders!

We are one Trump-friendly poll away from resolution

Nate Silver telegraphed this every day for the last week, yet the August/Never shares were still mispriced

538's model has come back online and is showing a 58% chance of a Harris win;

https://projects.fivethirtyeight.com/2024-election-forecast/

The same question as this market, but for 538's forecast is here:

/SimonGrayson/when-will-trump-overtake-harris-in-tq3ucuxus2

Related market: /Ziddletwix/if-rfk-drops-out-what-odds-will-nat

Particularly if you think RFK dropping out could throw a curveball in the current odds (looks like there will be some meaningful changes to the model)

Nate's convention bounce adjustment might start punishing Harris for not polling 2-3 points higher two weeks from today. It's an unusual year and you could argue she already had the "bounce" from securing the nomination.

opened a Ṁ1,000 He will not overtake... YES at 75% order

Can’t see this happening unless Harris horribly fumbles the debates or otherwise has a HUGE liability like Clinton’s emails.

bought Ṁ15 August YES

she's at 54% now, there was a 3% change (from 57%) just in the last few days..

A slight improvement for Harris in the model.

She’s now shown as having a 55% chance of winning the election!

If you're as excited as me about Nate Silver's election forecast, you're probably also waiting to see what 538's model is going to show...

/SimonGrayson/when-will-538-publish-their-harris

/ManifoldPolitics/when-538s-next-model-comes-out-what