https://www.twitch.tv/claudeplayspokemon
Claude Plays Pokemon is a Twitch stream where the AI chatbot Claude attempts to beat Pokemon Red. Once the game is reset, all remaining answers resolve NO, even if the stream continues with a new game.
I am N/Aing anything that is annoying to resolve. If I have to pore over multiple days of twitch VODs to figure out which way an answer resolves, I am not going to bother.
Update 2025-03-25 (PST) (AI summary of creator comment): Clarification on valid run criteria:
Only the instance where Claude goes from Mt. Moon to Cerulean City counts as a valid run.
A subsequent entry into Mt. Moon that leads him to exit through the entrance and wander back to Viridian City does not count.
In cases where the second attempt deviates from the stated route, the option will resolve NO.
Update 2025-05-12 (PST) (AI summary of creator comment): Clarification on 'pokemon types': Refers to elemental types (e.g., Bug, Grass, Normal), not different Pokemon species.
1,000People are also trading
@AhronMaline The answer is referring to types like Bug, Grass, Normal, not different species.
Going from https://www.reddit.com/r/ClaudePlaysPokemon/comments/1j3kwhc/claude_plays_pok%C3%A9mon_megathread/, Claude currently has 7 different types:
Grass (Sprou)
Poison (Sprou)
Normal (Star)
Ground (DUGTRIO)
Flying (Sand)
Bug (Leafy)
Water (Splash)
@ointment Also
Claude enters Rock Tunnel before Step 150,000
The streamer ClaudePlaysPokemon announces that there will be a reset before step 200000
Claude reaches Lavender Town before Step 200,000
@JoeandSeth Already resolved, it was just to help the resolution with all these questions haha. Ty anyway
All answers pertaining to Gemini are ill defined. Gemini's setup is very different from Claude's. Gemini gets a large scale map automatically that gets filled in as tiles are explored, so he can see beyond the current screen. This is an external input, not something Gemini makes by itself.
This is a huge advantage, and makes the two experiments incomparable.
Gemini also gets a tile-by-tile definition of each tile, so it can see cuttable trees for example. It doesn't have to understand the images.
@Mqrius Does anyone care that Gemini is cheating? I can resolve the answers N/A if people are up in arms about this, inclined to just let its results stand though even though it has an advantage over Claude
@SaviorofPlant I dunno I have no stakes in this. Just saying it's ambiguous what would count or not. Gemini is a few steps to the right on a continuous scale to things like "A human is playing and the AI tells the human what to do" or vice versa.
This is more of a problem for an answer like this ("another AI model surpasses Claude (gym badges)"), which is about any AI model. Less of a problem with an answer like "Gemini advances further (overall; not instantaneously) than Claude at any point", where we can assume it's about the GeminiPlaysPokemon stream no matter its advantages (but it would still be better if that was explicitly stated!).
@Mqrius I made it just to capture if progress will be faster with a different model/setup. Claude is also “cheating” by having direct access to some of the memory and pathing tools. It seems unlikely right now that we’ll see two models with the exact same setup, token usage rate, etc. in a controlled experiment even though that would be more interesting.
I would contend that any setup where the decisions are not made based on input and output from a statistical model should not count (I.e. a custom traditional video game AI with a series of if statements and predefined algorithms coded in). The rest is going to be subjective matters of degree and not kind until someone runs a model which can only see the actual screen and only press specific buttons more closely analogous to an actual human interacting with a gameboy.
@No_uh i realized i didn't include the screenshot. i think 34 to 1 is the best ive ever come out on a bet here
[deleted]