Also see this question, for Jan 1 2025.
In the future, it might be possible for general-purpose forecasting platforms to accept functions as forecasts. Question writers would provide function definitions, and forecasters would provide programmatic functions.
This workflow would be significantly more complicated than current forecasting platform workflows, but it could be far more scalable and general.
There are some platforms like Kaggle that might have arguably done this for very limited domains and uses. However, forecasting platforms like Manifold/Metaculus/Prediction Markets are much more general-purpose and have a different workflow.
Definitions
"Popular Forecasting platform"
A forecasting website, like Manifold/Metaculus/Kalshi. It must have at least 100 unique users per month to qualify.
"Function definitions as forecasting questions"
A question writer can propose a fairly-arbitrary function definition. For example, "For any time T from 2024 to 2030, and any stock ticker name, predict the company valuation".
(time: [2024 to 2030], tickerName: string) => distribution
Forecasters would forecast by uploading programming functions or providing API endpoints that would call programming functions.
Will a popular forecasting platform accept function definitions as forecasting questions by Jan 1, 2028?
11
Ṁ190Ṁ2212028
75%
chance
1H
6H
1D
1W
1M
ALL
This question is managed and resolved by Manifold.
Market context
Get
1,000 to start trading!
Which prediction markets and forecasting platforms will still be opening new markets/questions through 2028?
In Jan 2028, will non-profit decision making commonly use forecasting processes? [Resolves to Poll]
10% chance
In Jan 2028, will getting opinions from top forecaster be commonplace in non-profit decision making? [Resolves to Poll]
22% chance
Will I (@Bayesian) be a superforecaster before 2027?
9% chance
Will the NWS stop providing weather forecasts before 2027?
6% chance
Will Metaculus still exist and have active forecasting throughout 2026?
98% chance
Will Metaculus still exist and have active forecasting throughout 2030?
84% chance
Will Metaculus still exist and have active forecasting throughout 2035?
41% chance
In Jan 2028, will prediction markets occupy a new product vertical? [Resolves to Poll]
33% chance
Will any of my questions be in Manifold Predictle by EOY 2027?
33% chance