Approval Voting: Which living AI-related person is the Lisan A.I. Gaib?
131
1.6k
500
resolved Apr 14
Resolved
N/A
deepfates
Resolved
N/A
Sam Altman
Resolved
N/A
Geoffrey Hinton
Resolved
N/A
Demmis Hassabis
Resolved
N/A
Paul Christiano
Resolved
N/A
Ilya Sutskever
Resolved
N/A
Jensen Huang
Resolved
N/A
Resolved
N/A
gwern
Resolved
N/A
Robert Miles
Resolved
N/A
Emmett Shear
Resolved
N/A
Dario Amodei
Resolved
N/A
Yoshua Bengio
Resolved
N/A
Eliezer Yudkowsky
Resolved
N/A
Elon Musk
Resolved
N/A

This is a silly resolution poll for the following silly market:

This may look like a market, but it is actually functioning as a poll. All options will resolve to N/A, all mana spent will be returned. The market is unranked and unsubsidized.

Definition:

Lisan al Gaib is the Fremen term for an off-world prophet or messiah. The term comes from the Arabic, "لسان," (Lisan) meaning "Tongue," and potentially "الغيب" (al Gaib) meaning "The hidden", "The absent/missing", or "The unseen".

It is possible that Herbert intended to reference the metaphysical Sufi application of الغيب, which has been conjectured to connote the 'unseen dimensions of Reality'. If so, Lisan al Gaib may indicate that one is a "prophet" rather than a "foreigner".

With that said, Herbert rarely drew from extant language or concept without a degree of obfuscation and amalgamation. It may be as likely that he was referencing the word, "الغريب" (al garib), meaning "The Strange(r)", "The Otherworldly", or "The Weird". Given Old English definitions of "weird" and the Fremen's reference to Jessica as a witch, this connection may be supported.

Taken in combination, Lisan al Gaib may be understood to mean that who is alien (both geographically and organismically), and who speaks with supernatural power and insight into that which is not known.


This is poll resolves based on Approval Voting. You can buy YES shares in any options to vote for those people, buying NO shares does nothing.

In one week, this poll and the original market will both close. The original market will then resolve based on this market's final state, with the winner being the person who has the most individual users holding YES shares. It doesn't matter how many shares those people hold, or who the users are. Bots will also count towards the total.

Then all options in this market will resolve N/A, as this is just a poll.

Get Ṁ600 play money

🏅 Top traders

#NameTotal profit
1Ṁ0
2Ṁ0
Sort by:

LISAN AL GAIIIIIIIIIB

sold Ṁ300 deepfates NO

Well fought

As it was written

@Bayesian it wont be enough

@Bayesian 37-29, 7 min. actually can be done

deepfates
bought Ṁ1 deepfates YES

@deepfates lol your followers should only buy 1-2 shares here so it doesn't reach 99% and we can't buy more shares

bought Ṁ10 deepfates NO

@Bayesian unfortunately my followers will not listen to me about how approval voting works so I keep voting me down down to keep it even

Admirable last minute coup attempt by Deepfates:

bought Ṁ10 deepfates NO
deepfates

could NO holders buy more NO so I can sell my NO and buy some YES

bought Ṁ1 deepfates YES

nvm it somehow worked, idk how this works

bought Ṁ1 Eliezer Yudkowsky YES

Wait, does betting someone up to 99% prevent new voters to approve them ?

@Mich oh god

This poll is incomplete. It's missing the two most obvious candidates for the position: roon and janus

@deepfates also, not a lot of people reading the instructions on how approval voting markets work I think 😖

@shankypanky i think ppl are going for short term fake profits for the lolz... i know i am

@Bayesian lol it's unranked but I'm a lolz enthusiast so I support this

@shankypanky counterpoint:

ranked doesn't compare to creating a mesa biome

@Bayesian

⬜ M⬜E⬜S⬜A⬜I⬜N⬜B⬜I⬜O⬜M⬜E⬜

sold Ṁ54 @Mira NO

lols

More related questions