Will the Steve Kirsch/Rootclaim bet about COVID-19 vaccine deaths go through?
Basic
8
Ṁ587Jan 1
86%
chance
1D
1W
1M
ALL
This question is managed and resolved by Manifold.
Get
1,000
and3.00
Sort by:
Initially, each Judge must score 0 on the following scoring system
Decision The Judges will attempt to evaluate whether, in the US, the lives
saved by the mRNA COVID-19 vaccines are more or less than the
deaths they caused, as of January 1st, 2023.
Each judge will issue one of three decisions:
1. Score +1: The evidence better supports the hypothesis that
the vaccines resulted in more people being alive.
2. Score -1: The evidence better supports the hypothesis that
the vaccines resulted in less people being alive.
3. Score 0: The evidence supports both hypotheses at about the
same level.
For the pre-debate vote, this score can also indicate that a
judge has not studied the issue enough to reach a +1 or -1
vote.
It's going to be pretty hard to find people that score 0 AND that you'd trust with a 1 million dollar decision.
The rootclaim approach of claiming to objectively quantify likelihoods on binary questions and then finding it reasonable for judges to say they're still at 50/50 when all the evidence is in is odd. It would be way better if there were a requirement to vote up or down; even if the judges end up close to 50/50, they're still on one side or the other if they consider any evidence at all.
Related questions
Related questions
Will the Steve Kirsch/Rootclaim bet about COVID-19 vaccine deaths resolve to a tie?
35% chance
Will Steve Kirsch win their bet with Rootclaim over vaccine deaths?
13% chance
If Steve Kirsch loses their bet with Rootclaim over COVID-19 vaccine deaths, will they pay the money?
90% chance
If Rootclaim loses their bet with Steve Kirsch over COVID-19 vaccine deaths, will they pay the money?
92% chance
Scott Alexander is planning a COVID origins bet. If there is a debate, will judges conclude COVID came from a lab leak?
33% chance
Will @PeterMillerc030 bet at least $1000 USD against @EliezerYudkowsky on the origins of Covid19 before 2025?
2% chance
Will Rootclaim debate covid origins a second time?
30% chance
Will there be a second Rootclaim debate in 2024?
60% chance
If Scott Alexander organizes a Covid Origins Debate, will judges rule for lab leak? [Resolves 50% if no debate by 2025]
52% chance
Will Rootclaim change their COVID origins probability by at least 30% by end of 2024?
13% chance