Skip to main content
MANIFOLD
Will I cooperate with any Manifolder who defected on me by the end of 2023?
12
Ṁ210Ṁ3.7k
resolved Jan 2
Resolved
NO

Some of the more "fun" Manifold markets tend to have a lot of back room deals to perform certain types of market manipulation and share mana via manalink. These rely largely on trust, and are unenforceable.

This presents a temporal collective action problem with myself. If someone makes a deal with me and then reneges, I have no way to punish them at the time, and they get to walk away with a hefty profit. Then the next time an opportunity for a deal comes around, it would hurt me to not be willing to work with them.

The best avenue around this is to demonstrate a credible committment to not agree to deals with anyone who has previously broken a deal with me. Hence this market.

I will not bet on YES or sell any NO in this market.

Note that this only applies to clearly-specified explicit deals, not implied ones. It doesn't apply to any deals I may have forgotten about before creating this market. And it doesn't apply if them backing out of the deal was done with my consent.

Market context
Get
Ṁ1,000
to start trading!

🏅 Top traders

#TraderTotal profit
1Ṁ422
2Ṁ11
3Ṁ9
4Ṁ2
5Ṁ0
Sort by:

what is a clearly specified explicit deal? can you clearly specify positive and negative examples for this? Have I defected on you by betting no at a time when consensus was trending no on your 69% market?

predictedNO

@L No, I'm referring only to a verbal agreement, like "I will bet M$1000 on YES in that market". Just betting against me in some gamble market is not defecting against me, since you had never told me you wouldn't do it!