Will DALL-E 3 be able to count?
25
450Ṁ17k
resolved Dec 30
Resolved
NO

Current image models are terrible at this. Whenever I first get access to DALL-E 3, I will give it 10 basic numerical prompts. In at least 90% of those prompts, at least 50% of the images must have the correct number of objects.

If one object is partially cut off by the edge of the image, it counts towards the total as long as I can clearly tell that it's the correct type of object. If not all of the objects are clearly visible, I'll count it if it seems like something a reasonable human artist would be likely to do from the same image description. It's ok if it gets other details of the image wrong, it only needs to get the number of objects correct.

Here are the specific prompts:

  • 9 balls lying on a field

  • A flock of 40 pigeons

  • 25 eggs in a kitchen

  • A 7-armed starfish

  • A football team of 11 players

  • 4 light bulbs on the ceiling

  • A pack of 8 wolves

  • A houseplant with exactly 30 leaves

  • A rectangular grid of 100 dots

  • An archipelago of 15 islands

Get
Ṁ1,000
to start trading!

🏅 Top traders

#NameTotal profit
1Ṁ144
2Ṁ104
3Ṁ52
4Ṁ48
5Ṁ26
Sort by:
predictedNO

Tried the first one then hit the usage cap, I'll try the rest later. It needs to get all 9 correct in order for this to resolve YES.

That's more than 40.

predictedNO

And just in case it thought I meant "at least", here's the result of the "exactly 30 leaves" prompt.

It'd be nice to have the prompts or at least the numbers

predictedNO

@NoaNabeshima Sure. Anything in particular you'd like me to test?

@IsaacKing Nope! I just think the probability I'd assign is fairly prompt and numbers dependent

predictedNO

@NoaNabeshima Ok, exact prompts added.

How high are you planning to go with the numbers?

predictedYES

@firstuserhere For high counts of people, will DALLE-3 be able to keep them from morphing together?

@firstuserhere As high as I can before it becomes difficult to tell how many objects are actually there.

Similar:

© Manifold Markets, Inc.Terms + Mana-only TermsPrivacyRules