Are you in favor of giving $1,000 Universal Basic Income (UBI) to every adult in the US? *Raise the floor*
26
239
490
resolved Jan 1
Resolved
YES

The Alaska Permanent Fund is a fund for all residents of the U.S. state of Alaska which averages $1,600 annually (in 2019 currency), and is sometimes described as the only example of a real basic income in practice.

The idea of providing a basic income to all members of society goes back centuries. The 16th century English philosopher and statesman Thomas More mentions the idea in his best-known work, Utopia.

Thomas Paine, a pamphleteer whose ideas helped spur the American Revolution, proposed a tax plan in which revenues would provide a stream of government income “to every person, rich or poor.”

And Martin Luther King, Jr., proposed “guaranteed income” in his book Where Do We Go from Here: Chaos or Community? published in 1967.

The American Rescue Plan, signed by President Biden on March 11, 2021, included generous tax breaks to low- and moderate-income people.

Data shows that the injection of funds is what allowed people to keep it together over the late pandemic and even now into the current inflationary environment.

Get Ṁ600 play money

🏅 Top traders

Sort by:

If everyone has $1,000 then no one has $1,000. Money only has value because it is comparative. This is simply inflationary.

@JasonHerrera UBI is not printing new money, but redistributing existing money. UBI can boost the economy and reduce poverty, without causing inflation. Especially within local economies.

@HumanITy The implementation matters a lot for whether I'm "in favor" of it; where is the existing money being taken from for this redistribution?

@JamieWahls implement a taxation of automation for the removal of paid human workforce. Still cheaper than the cost of human labor & allows for reimbursement into the working economy.

predicted YES

@JasonHerrera That is not how money works at all. Cash does not have value because I have it and you don’t. The current value basis for the USD is debt. The suggestion that value is derived from inequality is ludicrous.

predicted NO

@HumanITy Automation doesn’t pay tax. Its owners do, and they pass the added cost on to consumers, who pay with after-tax cash. This is just another tax.

For every $1000 of “free money” distributed, about $300 will be ground up in the gears of Washington.

If you want to make an impact, CUT TAXES by $1000 per capita. No friction, direct spending money in your pocket.

predicted NO

@SpaceboyLuke This is how money works. That’s what gives it value.

bought Ṁ10 of YES

How does this resolve?

Comment hidden

@Paul TBD.

More related questions