Once I realized "Getaway Car" was shared, I was curious how many other examples there were. By searching scryfall.com for any Taylor Swift names that sounded plausible, I got this list (minus Wildest Dreams which @audrey found after I missed it):

1. "Last Kiss" from TS's Speak Now (Oct. 2010) and MTG's Rise of the Eldrazi (Apr. 2010)

2. "Starlight" from TS's Red (2012) and MTG's Portal (1997)

3. "Wildest Dreams" from TS's 1989 (2014) and MTG's Kaladesh (2016)

4. "Exile" from TS's folklore (2020) and MTG's Alliances (1996)

5. "Getaway Car" from TS's reputation (2017) and MTG's Streets of New Capenna (2022)

6. "Karma" from TS's Midnights (2022) and MTG's Limited Edition Alpha (1993)

The first example includes the song and card releasing in the same year! And the last two examples are both new to 2022.

Capitalization doesn't matter for this market. Neither do parentheticals like "feat. Bon Iver." Titles do matter though, so Ivy, Gleeful Spellthief is distinct from the song "ivy". Spacing also matters.

With bigger corpora than ever, the breakneck speed of MTG releases these days as well as Taylor's Versions and a new album (/Arnav1312/will-taylor-swift-release-a-new-alb) on the horizon, will there be another name shared by a Taylor Swift song and a Magic: The Gathering card by end of 2024? (It must be a new example, not just one I missed that already existed.)

See also /Conflux/will-the-next-taylor-swift-songmagi

General policy for my markets: In the rare event of a conflict between my resolution criteria and the agreed-upon common-sense spirit of the market, I may resolve it according to the market's spirit or N/A, probably after discussion.