Will Manifold set abandoned questions to resolve to MKT, by default?
25
246Ṁ2611resolved Jan 3
Resolved
NO1H
6H
1D
1W
1M
ALL
@MilliOnaire is working on a way to automatically resolve markets to MKT probability, after a certain period of time. I think this is quite a good thing - it means that traders can free up
- For abandoned markets, someone else can come in and provide liquidity, and bet the MKT to what they think it should be
- If they're wrong, then other traders will seek to profit out of them
- It's decentralizing the resolution criteria by using a keynesian beauty contest
- what grounds the resolution is both 1) the community opinion on the resolution and 2) the possibility of the creator coming back
My current proposal:
The auto-MKT-resolve date defaults to 7 days after "criteria date". This is changeable by the creator (but not set in the creation screen, similar to the tagging interface)
on "criteria date", creator auto-withdrawals all liquidity. But holders of YES/NO shares can continue to trade on the same market if someone else provides liquidity.
One major alternative: Markets could resolve to N/A automatically instead. @JamesGrugett likes this because it prevents the possibility of "gaming" the system - if you think a market will be abandoned, you can manipulate the price right before the auto-resolve.
I think gaming is possible, but the lost profits from traders will be worse (especially for traders who already exited via selling their shares). And what's nice is that the auto-MKT-resolution also punishes the creator financially by draining their liquidity and sending it to the other traders, rather than letting them get off scot-free in the N/A case.
Also, there are possible fixes to prevent gaming (eg - using the weighted average of the prob between the criteria date and the resolution time, or picking a random prob point in time from the last 24h, or something; I think the game theory works out okay on these)
This question is managed and resolved by Manifold.
Get
1,000 to start trading!
🏅 Top traders
# | Name | Total profit |
---|---|---|
1 | Ṁ293 | |
2 | Ṁ62 | |
3 | Ṁ46 | |
4 | Ṁ16 | |
5 | Ṁ16 |
People are also trading
Related questions
Manifold moderator resolves this question?
24% chance
Will Manifold ever stop misresolving their own markets?
82% chance
When will the final resolved market on Manifold be resolved?
When will Manifold Markets allow users to partially resolve multiple choice markets
Will Manifold let AI autoresolve markets by 2028?
49% chance