Will Congressional stock trades outperform the S&P 500 by more than 10 percentage points in 2023?
125
1.4kṀ10k
resolved Jan 11
Resolved
NO

Since the STOCK Act of 2012 made it a legal requirement for Congress to disclose financial transactions, a clear pattern has emerged: they always beat the market. In 2022, $SPY fell 18.2%, but the weighted index of Congressional trades fell less than 1%. Will resolve at the end of 2023 using data from the US Clerk's Office and NYSE, more intuitive visuals can be found here and here.

Market context
Get
Ṁ1,000
to start trading!

🏅 Top traders

#NameTotal profit
1Ṁ1,160
2Ṁ960
3Ṁ127
4Ṁ117
5Ṁ116
Sort by:
predictedNO

@creator Please resolve

@such There seems to be a huge discrepancy in the different indexes. KRUZ is at -1%, NANC is at 7% (but these only exist since February). Meanwhile the Optiver congress Buy shows ~30% and the long-short shows ~20%. Which of these will be used for resolution?

predictedNO

If it was up to me, I would go with Optiver long-short. I don't see a reason to not include sells, and the ETFs suffer from a lag behind congress trades. Even a small lag can cause a big difference if the congress trades themselves and algo-trading that follows them moves the price.

@Shump yeah sells are certainly included, I'm using the long-short for resolution

predictedNO

@such You know what, the Optiver long-short is not a good indicator either. It's leveraged to 160% and weighs down sells by some arbitrary amount. It's quite obvious that such an index would do better than S&P 500 in a year with gains because of the leverage, just because of leverage.

None of these indexes track the actual pofits of congresspeople well.

@Shump this was what I originally was planning on resolving with, thoughts?

predictedYES

@such maybe divide the return of the Optiver long short by 1.6 to compensate for the leverage?

@Daniel_MC will resolve with Quiver Quantitative's long-short index, which is 130% levered long and 30% levered short. I'll divide both to compensate for the leverage

a couple questions:

(1) is this by more than 10 percentage points, or more than 10 percent? for ex:

(1.a) if SPY gains 5%, and congress gains 5.06%, congress made > 10% of the SPY’s gains.

(1.b) if SPY gains 5%, and congress gains 16%, congress made > 10% of the SPY’s gains.

which of these resolves positively? 1.a, 1.b, or both?

(2) how are you tracking “congress”? is there some ETF or other aggregate?

@SaulMunn yeah great question, probably should have worded this market more clearly. To clarify, I mean 10 percentage points, so only 1.b would resolve positively. As far as tracking, there are 2 ETFs ($NANC for the Democratic Party and $KRUZ for the GOP) that I can use to track, but there are also websites like quiverquant.com that display the data and when it comes time to resolve the market I'll double-check everything with the actual raw data submitted to the US Clerk's Office.

@such okay thank you!!

Pretty clever market

Comment hidden
© Manifold Markets, Inc.TermsPrivacy