Will Kamala Harris flip a state?
88
𝕊866
Nov 5
52%
chance

Will Kamala Harris flip a state in the 2024 presidential election?

Flipping a state means she wins a state not won by Joe Biden in 2020.

Maine or Nebraska's congressional districts do not count. For example, if Kamala Harris wins Maine's second district, that doesn't resolve this question.

This question closes a day before the election, and resolves as soon as results are known.

If for whatever reason the Democratic nominee changes this question will be about the new nominee.

Versions for Trump:

This question is managed and resolved by Manifold.
Get
Ṁ1,000
and
S1.00
Sort by:
opened a Ṁ500 YES at 51% order

Updated description: If for whatever reason the Democratic nominee changes this question will be about the new nominee.

@bagelfan more than 2m Americans have already voted. More than 440k have voted in just one state.

@becauseyoudo It’s very very unlikely but questions should ideally deal with foreseeable edge cases.

@bagelfan lol, someone getting afraid of Biden saying he's back in?

bought Ṁ50 YES

Missouri

@DaEpicFirestar Why would Missouri be any more likely than Florida or Texas, let alone North Carolina?

@DaEpicFirestar Missouri is Trump +20 or so this year. Trump +15 is the floor.

@BrandonRoney is right. This is an NC market. We need a market on how many states she flips.

@ScottSupak You guys can bet here on "whether this is a NC market" (in the sense that if it's "a NC market" then the market I just created should trade at around 0.

https://manifold.markets/EricNeyman/will-kamala-harris-lose-nc-but-win?play=true

@EricNeyman good idea for a market, and of course it's possible--especially now with the disaster possibly affecting the election--that another state could flip while NC doesn't, and my tone is only meant as a suggestion that the price should be low, and your market is priced pretty well at 8c.

This is at almost 53% according to Nate Silver's model. ~13% of that comes from states other than NC (NC is at ~40%)...his model seems bullish on Harris' chances in Florida and especially Alaska, so probably the 13% comes mostly from those states.

@Nightsquared That is the wrong way to think about this market. How many universes are there in which NC goes red and another Solid R state like FL, AK, or IA goes blue? That's like maybe on the order of magnitude of 1 in a 100 or 1 in a 1000. Not happening. The equation is that probability plus p(Harris wins NC). So essentially p(Harris wins NC) is the market value here.

@BrandonRoney I mean, I mostly agree, but Nate Silver's model doesn't. I get the impression that these models give too much credence to bizarre outcomes, but who knows.

@Nightsquared Nate Silver is pretty overrated. Its too dependent on weights of polls that have awful records when Trump is on the ballot.

@Nightsquared No, actually you just don’t understand Nate Silver’s model.

@Nightsquared I didn't think Nate Silver's model gave a probability of Harris flipping a state.

@PlasmaBallin

"Harris wins at least one state Trump won in 2020"

@Nightsquared I think the "Harris flips a state but loses NC" probability is coming mostly from Alaska. I don't have access to the model any more, but last time I did, it had Alaska at ~25%. And it has the weakest correlation with other states.

@Nightsquared I stand corrected. Didn’t think he would be that dumb

@PlasmaBallin Do you think Nate would take a Harris Alaska +400 bet?

@BrandonRoney not really, the NC market has Harris’ chances at 45%. Right now, this market is at 51%; of that, 45% comes from Harris flipping NC (and maybe another state), and 6% from Harris flipping another state but not NC.

@BonjTwo Not only is NC mispriced, but that 6% is overpriced. That is my entire point.

@BrandonRoney https://manifold.markets/Nightsquared/will-kamala-harris-flip-a-state-but-v6ddgu13hj?play=true
I have a limit order at 1% which you can take if you think this is definitely not gonna happen.