The battlefield is an Olympic sized swimming pool that is 6 feet deep. A fully grown polar bear (9 feet tall) faces off against a fully grown female Great White Shark. The fight is to the death and neither animal will attempt to escape the pool. Both animals immediately see each other as a threat and are agressive towards each other but they wont blindly charge at each other unless that is how they would typically fight in the wild. Both animals will fight with the intelligence/strategy that is typical of average members of their species.
This poll will be used to resolve this market: /Zeolite/what-animal-does-manifold-believe-w
The poll will remain up for 1 week.
Making arguments in the comments to sway future voters to your side is encouraged.
I will not be moderating/removing votes obtained from paying for them/alts/other shenanigans as that would be way too much effort and probably couldnt be done reliably. I would appreciate though if those types of things were kept out of it as it makes these types of questions and the site better when shenanigans are kept strictly to markets where they are encouraged.
1,000People are also trading
The pool is way too shallow for the shark. The polar bear stands head and shoulders above while the shark is essentially trapped in a glorified puddle. Those sharks often hunt by utilizing depth, the pools shallowness cripples them significantly. Otherwise, the shark would obviously win.
Furthermore, the polar bear's first likely move to deliver a crushing blow with its massive, 12-inch-wide paws since that's how it often reacts to threats in water.
A single, full-force swipe from a polar bear can shatter a walrus's skull. When that paw strikes the shark’s snout, the shark will be really dazed.
Finally, the shark needs to constantly keep moving to continue breathing which is difficult in a fight to the death in a small pool.
After reading a previous comment, I want to adress two things : first of all, the polar bear is unlikely to lack for air due to its buoyancy. Second of all, the polar bear doesn't need much leverage to strike, they often fight by grappling. As long as the severely restricted shark doesn't land a first lucky bite, the polar bear is likely to latch on with its massive claws and clamp down out of reach of the mouth of the shark.
Finally, the shark is unable to achieve proper velocity because of the small size of the pool.
If you are really curious, the video below happened in Egypt, with a tiger shark (which is huge, but only one quarter of the size of a great white shark) attacking a human.
WARNING - very disturbing.
It would be very similar with a bear. You can see the shark doesn't need any distance or speed to attack. A great white shark has 6 times the muscle mass of a polar bear, and it can exert that force very effectively in the water.
Regardless, what I think would actually happen is that the shark would only attack if it's hungry, and if it is hungry, it might not even bother killing the bear, but might just take bites of it. That's what fish do.
The answer is polar bear because the pool is too shallow for the shark! Vote accordingly!
This comment in particular is what swayed me: https://manifold.markets/Zeolite/what-animal-does-manifold-believe-w#sq4sqgve6k
@MollTheCoder glad to have helped.
Reproducing here:
Pool floor is too slick. Bear can't get traction like it expects.
Blubber and fur make bear rather buoyant, no leverage for striking, striking force already greatly reduced through water as medium and lack of traction.
Bear can't easily pin the shark as it needs to do to bring teeth into play, teeth would have to be under water anyway to be effective. Breathing is a significant demand on the bear's positioning.
Bear standing is easily knocked out of stance, spends significant energy to reposition. Shark has much more efficient movement.
Shark easily.