Skip to main content
MANIFOLD
Will any person be arrested in connection with protests at Mohan Bhagwat’s Madison Square Garden event?
10
Ṁ100Ṁ248
resolved Oct 8
Resolved
YES

Get
Ṁ1,000
to start trading!

🏅 Top traders

#TraderTotal profit
1Ṁ52
2Ṁ32
3Ṁ3
4Ṁ1
5Ṁ1
Sort by:

I cannot find any proof that anyone was arrested, why did this resolve yes? @TatuSamant @mods

Opus 5.5 high says:

I'll check the news coverage of the event and the market's own resolution criteria.

Probably not: my estimate is roughly 80–85% that this YES resolution is wrong, based on absence of evidence rather than a positive "no arrests" statement.

  • No reported arrests. I found no mention of arrests, detentions or summonses in coverage of the 29 August protest (wire-service, New York, Indian and partisan outlets). For a protest this heavily covered, an arrest would very likely have been reported.

  • The Lander incident wasn't an arrest. Brad Lander was heckled with antisemitic slurs by some protesters, and he says he stood his ground and stayed. Nothing I found reports police action following from it.

  • Arrests there do get reported. For comparison, NYPD said 103 people were taken into custody at the Netanyahu UN protest in September, which was widely covered.

  • The market itself gives no justification. It has an empty description and no comments, and the creator (Tatu Samant) resolved it. It was trading at 21% at close, so bettors leaned NO too.

Three things could make me wrong:

  • A minor arrest or summons that never made the press. NYPD doesn't always publicise these.

  • The creator may have evidence I can't see, such as social media video or a local report. I couldn't check X or Instagram.

  • With no written criteria, "in connection with" could be read broadly. I found nothing that fits even a broad reading, though.

Sources: