When will the National Weather Service start using GraphCast?
1.2%
2023
4%
2024
91%
2025
1.8%
2026
1.7%
2027 or beyond

Resolves to "yes" when the National Weather Service admits to incorporating GraphCast into their modeling systems in ANY capacity (does NOT need to replace current models to resolve as "yes").

If you think the NWS will never use GraphCast, you can choose 2027 or beyond, as this question will resolve in January of 2028.

https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.adi2336

Get
Ṁ1,000
to start trading!
Sort by:
bought Ṁ250 YES

The latest NHC discussion on Chantal says: "The NHC track forecast lies close to the previous one, and the latest HCCA and Google Deep Mind solutions." So they are using it as part of their track forecast guidance, presumably.

bought Ṁ50 YES

There is a bit of a precedent with the NHC not using slightly better consensus aids for TCs for example. But this seems a lot harder to ignore. I for one am very excited to play around with it, even if the NWS won't admit that it is doing the same.

There are many ML models already and NWS may well develop their own or use the model ECMWF is developing. So GraphCast may never end up there. Or is this about ML models in general?

@scellus This is specifically about GraphCast. I assume ML is being explored by the NWS, but I specifically picked GraphCast because of the recent high profile Science paper and because seems like it would be easy to monitor for a definitive yes/no resolution.

Would it being mentioned in a forecast discussion from a single forecast office be an example that would lead to a YES resolution?

@kalassak Yes, that'd be sufficient to lead to a YES resolution, but it'd have to be specifically from a NWS forecast office, and to my knowledge the NWS is pretty unified in their policies/procedures and use of models. I think it unlikely a single forecast office would use this without the US government deciding to formally "allow" it to supplement pre-existing models.

© Manifold Markets, Inc.TermsPrivacy