In USD, how much are M$100 in profits worth?
Basic
8
Ṁ234
resolved Apr 16
Resolved
5.7

How much value, in USD, does M$100 in profits have?

I've noticed that although M$100 is theoretically worth less than a dollar, people are willing to put much more energy into winning it than that number would suggest. Maybe because they're trading for fun instead of finances, or maybe they want to win mana because that's how Manifold keeps score.

To resolve this, I will either devise an informal test to run, wait for one of you to do it for me, or resolve to the market probability at a random date and time in the week before the close date. Given that discretion, I will not be trading in this market.

See also:

Sep 22, 1:18pm: I've extended the close date by a week because I have my hands full working on a bot for the trading bot contest, so I want some extra time to figure out how to run an informal test on this. If this has been disruptive for anyone please let me know.

Sep 22, 3:39pm: For clarity, this question includes the additional M$100 assumed to be in your account, not just the raw leaderboard numbers themselves.

Get
Ṁ1,000
and
S3.00
Sort by:

I put off figuring out a way to test for this. Eventually enough time had passed that a test would no longer reflect the facts as they stood while the market was open. Sorry guys! Resolving to market probability in accordance with the final possible resolution criterion I described.

How do you plan on resolving this?

"Maybe because they're trading for fun instead of finances"

I mean, no maybe about it. Literally no person on earth is trading on Manifold for their personal finances, because mana can't be redeemed for money. This is a classic personal utility vs economic value thing. 100 mana in profits is worth less than a dollar (trivially so) but is worth people's time because people who bet on Manifold enjoy the experience.

For me personally, the answer is unambiguously M$100 = USD$1. The fact that you can buy mana at that rate, and donate it at that rate, keeps us anchored at that rate!

@dreev ceiling aka purchase price =/= market value. Mana is gift cards!

@MattP (Agreed it's a cap. See discussion in the linked market.)

@dreev this would imply that the correct value for this market is 0.0, given this is asking about profits and not mana.

@Adam I'm confused about the difference. Mana is mana is money, from my perspective. Doesn't matter how I get it.

@dreev If you get it from trading, you also get higher on the leaderboard, other people trust your predictions more, etc. Some people value these things.

@dreev But if you won it from somebody else, you get to be on the leaderboards.

@MichaelWheatley @Yev Super fair. Personally I'm gunning for the proposed altruism leaderboard, for those who've spent the most on subsidizing markets or bounties or other ways of spending mana for the benefit of the community.

(I'm still confused by @Adam's claim about some way someone could value mana profit less. You're talking about ways someone might value it more, and I agree with that.)

@dreev I assume this question is asking about how much you value leaderboard profit, not the mana you profited?

(i.e. winning 100m in a bet nets you 100m and the leaderboard profit)

@Adam My intention was that it was both, since 100 in profits entails an extra 100 in your account as well.

@MichaelWheatley not necessarily; people have found a variety of ways (some of which have been patched) to gain account-profits without earning M$.

unrelatedly, if anybody would like to purchase Manifold profits at the current price indicated by this market DM me on discord :P

Related questions

© Manifold Markets, Inc.Terms + Mana-only TermsPrivacyRules