Will Ukraine regain control of central Bakhmut by the end of May 2023?
46
closed May 31
0.7%
chance

From https://metaculus.com/questions/16743/ukraine-regains-bakhmut-before-june-2023/

Some 10½ months ago, on February 24th, 2022, Russia invaded Ukraine. Their concept of operations apparently involved rapidly taking the capital, deposing the government, and largely completing the country's conquest before Western countries could co-ordinate on a reaction. By April 2022, after fierce Ukrainian resistance and serious deficiencies in Russian military preparedness defeated this plan, Russia shifted focus to the Donets Basion (Donbas) region in the country's east, where conditions were more favorable. This offensive also bogged down quickly, and Russia's offensive ambitions continually narrowed into the summer until they were focused ultimately around the town of Bakhmut, where operations were being conducted largely by the "Wagner Group" private army under Yevgeny Prigozhin instead of by the regular Russian army.

By fall, Bakhmut was described as an obsession for Russia and a "meat grinder" into which its best forces were being wastefully thrown. Nonetheless, the Bakhmut offensive continued, with some analysts speculating that it was essentially a propaganda operation designed to provide Russian President Putin with a "victory" to offset mounting defeats, or even motivated by Prigozhin's personal financial interests.

On December 20th, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy visited Bakhmut to show support for the defenders. On January 6th, Russia launched a powerful assault on the adjacent town of Soledar, where Ukrainian officials acknowledged the situation was "difficult.".

After months of fighting Russia made incremental gains in Bakhmut, with the city administrative building allegedly falling to Russian troops in April.

On May 5, the head of the Wagner Group, the Russian paramilitary organization leading the offensive, said that Wagner would withdraw from the battle because of lack of Russian support.

Sort by:
NamesAreHard avatar
NamesAreHardis predicting NO at 0.7%

@MetaculusBot @dglid Resolves NO :)

Fedor avatar
Fedorbought Ṁ100 of YES

I think the chance is not 50%, but metacalculus had moved up to 35% & the Ukrainian army is doing counterattacks at the flanks https://twitter.com/TheStudyofWar/status/1657202866627420165

jack avatar
Jackis predicting NO at 20%

For end of June:

DjjRiri avatar
Djj Riri
Comment hidden
RjduDususu avatar
Rjdu Dususu

Worthless, poorly defined question that only proves manifold and metaculus are retards sites. The only good thing is manifold is too dumb to ban me.

You may instead check out my question.

ShadowyZephyr avatar
ShadowyZephyr

@RjduDususu This coming from someone who has consistently made some of the worst markets on Manifold.

Schwabilismus avatar
Schwabilismusis predicting NO at 20%

@RjduDususu I wonder why you wrote a thing like that. Do you want people to not trade on your market? Because after reading your comment I surely don't want to.

DjjRiri avatar
Djj Riri
Comment hidden
Schwabilismus avatar
Schwabilismusis predicting NO at 20%

@DjjRiri oh now I get it. You are just are paranoid and delusional. Must be frustrating for to try and do forecasting if your beliefs so rarely match up with reality. At least that would explain the nasty attitude you exhibit in your comments.

Maybe you should.... Get some fresh air? Glass of water? Touch some grass?

ShadowyZephyr avatar
ShadowyZephyr

@Schwabilismus You made like 20 alts after getting banned and misresolving your AI market as well as others

DjjRiri avatar
Djj Riri
Comment hidden
Schwabilismus avatar
Schwabilismusis predicting NO at 20%

@ShadowyZephyr lol, okay.

DjjRiri avatar
Djj Riri

@Schwabilismus the repeated fails here are epic. Not only has every ai prediction ever made on manifold failed, but you're straight up pretending to not be a jack alt despite defending him and then voting opposite his predictions to donate mana.

Schwabilismus avatar
Schwabilismusis predicting NO at 20%

@DjjRiri but maybe I am defending Jack because he is right? Also maybe he is very good looking and smart?

OR: I am really another user trying to strengthen your belief that I am an alt account of Jack? Sounds funny? Yeah why should someone say Jack is good looking if he wasn't Jack.

But wait: If I wasn't Jack, why would I bet against him to donate money? Coincidence? Nothing is ever a coincidence! That sounds like something an alt-account of Jack would say!

You really are onto something here.

And those darm mods don't care to do what you think is right. The world is so unjust. And you are so smart.

@ShadowyZephyr : I am not going to comment on those markets because I know s*** about them and I really don't care. Maybe tell Jack about them?

ShadowyZephyr avatar
ShadowyZephyr

@Schwabilismus OMG, I just realize I tagged the wrong person, I meant to ping Djj Riri, who made 20 alts.

Schwabilismus avatar
Schwabilismusis predicting NO at 20%

@ShadowyZephyr Aw, okay. That sounds reasonable. Thanks for the heads up.

jack avatar
Jackis predicting NO at 20%

Speaking from experience, talking to the troll (https://manifold.markets/IsaacKing/will-mark-ingraham-be-gone-by-the-e#) is pointless, I just ignore Mark or leave a comment for everyone else explaining that they should ignore them, talking to Mark gets you nowhere.

Schwabilismus avatar
Schwabilismusis predicting NO at 20%

@jack okay, thanks.

Related markets

Will Ukraine regain control of central Bakhmut by the end of June?14%
Will Ukraine regain control of central Bakhmut by the end of July?21%
Will Ukraine have control over Crimea by the end of 202311%
Will Ukraine retake western Bakhmut by June 15?4%
Will Ukraine regain control over Crimea before the end of 2024?10%
Will Ukraine regain control of its pre-2014 territory (including Crimea and Donbas) by 2025?15%
Will the Ukrainian army pull out of Bakhmut by the end of June?14%
Will Ukraine retake the city of Donetsk before the end of 2023?12%
Will the Ukrainian army pull out of Bakhmut by the end of July?14%
Will the Ukraine war be over by the end of 2023?11%
Will Ukraine take back crimea by the end of 2023?20%
After the Ukrainian 2023 counteroffensive begins, will Russia withdraw from Bakhmut within one month?18%
Will Ukraine recapture more than 5% of the occupied territories during 2023?78%
Will Ukraine gain control of any parts of Russian pre-2014 territory by 2025?14%
Will Ukraine have partial control over Crimea by the end of 2026?47%
Will Ukraine control Armiansk before July 1, 2023?6%
Will Ukraine regain control of the Zaporizhzhia Nuclear Power Plant before January 1, 2024?68%
3. Will Ukraine control the city of Luhansk at the end of 2023?9%
Will Ukraine have full control over Crimea by the end of 2026?25%
After the Ukrainian 2023 counteroffensive begins, will Russia withdraw from Bakhmut within two weeks?18%