did you decide to do this in the end?

@shankypanky I think I'm leaning towards no. He doesn't seem interested in having true beliefs. He just came out with yet another idiotic post that reveals misunderstandings of basic logic and human psychology, and as far as I can tell he didn't even bother to respond to Scott's post defending EA.

The argument in favor is of course that it'd be primarily to convince the audience, not Freddie himself, but I don't have a large audience myself and I don't expect any significant fraction of Freddie's readers to see my post, so it seems kind of pointless.

resolving soon and it looks like the votes are tied here (at the time of this repost)

Looks like Scott's got it covered.

I for one am looking forward to reading your rebuttal