Will Ravel Kopelman’s question about whether Dr P’s question will resolve correctly resolve in the same way as Dr P’s question?
10
100Ṁ894resolved Mar 7
Resolved
NO1H
6H
1D
1W
1M
ALL
Close date updated to 2022-02-27 11:59 pm
Feb 25, 8:05am: For example, if they both resolve YES, this question resolves YES. If Dr P resolves NO and Ravel Kopelman resolves YES, this question resolves NO.
Close date updated to 2022-03-31 11:59 pm
Feb 28, 9:30am: if Ravel Kopelman resolves before Dr P (e.g. as N/A), I will consider that to mean that Dr P’s question will remain unresolved, and so my question will resolve YES.
Feb 28, 12:50pm: Hang on, my last update doesn’t make much sense. I should resolve NO in that case since the questions didn’t resolve the same. I feel suitably foolish.
This question is managed and resolved by Manifold.
Get
1,000 to start trading!
🏅 Top traders
# | Name | Total profit |
---|---|---|
1 | Ṁ16 | |
2 | Ṁ12 | |
3 | Ṁ12 | |
4 | Ṁ1 | |
5 | Ṁ0 |
People are also trading
Will P vs PSPACE be resolved before P vs NP?
72% chance
Will this question be resolved No?
47% chance
How will "How will the most entertaining question resolve?" not resolve?
49% chance
Will this question resolve to “No?”
46% chance
Will this question be resolved as “No”?
43% chance
will this question resolve as yes or no (resolves based on higher probability)
Will this question resolve no?
51% chance
Sort by:
I think it's pretty clear this question is asking whether both Ravel and Dr P's answers will both resolve to the same thing (YES/YES or NO/NO, maybe NA/NA).
This question will resolve to YES if:
YES/YES - Trump wins.
NO/NO - Ravel commits fraud.
NA/NA - Seems not possible, should be NA/NO. So again, not seeing this unless Ravel commits fraud.
So I agree with @Lorenzo, only way this doesn't get resolved as NO is if Trump wins or Ravel or Ferruginous (but maybe not both - because then this would be back to NO??) commit fraud. Not sure what the baseline rate of fraud is but bet it's way lower than 5% (Dr P with that specific Trump question obv a specific case).
As I see it: if Dr. P questions resolves as N/A Raven claimed to resolve as NO, which is very likely to be interpreted by FerruginousDuck as not resolving the same way. Indeed no claims were made for PROB, but it's highly unlikely to lead to a situation where the two questions resolve in ways that FerruginousDuck considers to be the same.
5% would be the chance of one of Ravel and FerruginousDuck resolving fraudulently, which I think is about right, maybe even a bit high
People are also trading
Related questions
Will P vs PSPACE be resolved before P vs NP?
72% chance
Will this question be resolved No?
47% chance
How will "How will the most entertaining question resolve?" not resolve?
49% chance
Will this question resolve to “No?”
46% chance
Will this question be resolved as “No”?
43% chance
will this question resolve as yes or no (resolves based on higher probability)
Will this question resolve no?
51% chance