Will I get Mythic on MTG Arena in 2023? (I just learned about its deceitful & exploitable secret ranking system, but might still try normally.)
21
349
390
resolved Jan 1
Resolved
NO

I've come pretty close on multiple occasions, but never quite there. I believe my record is Diamond 2. (The ranks go Bronze, Silver, Gold, Platinum, Diamond, Mythic, with tiers going from 4 down to 1.)

The complicating factor is that I recently learned about a bit of deceit that Arena does. Apparently, it keeps its own secret ranking of how good you actually are (whereas the public ranks are much more tied to how much you've played recently) and weights it a lot. (This matches my experience of sometimes being on an improbable winning streak with a new deck and then being unable to replicate it with the same deck at similar ranks.) In addition to mildly perverse incentives, this allows an exploit where you immediately concede a ton of games at the very bottom of a rank (it won't de-rank you mid-season) to tank your secret rating, then win a bunch of easy games. https://hareeb.com/2021/05/23/inside-the-mtg-arena-rating-system/

I would feel somewhat unsatisfied doing this exploit, though. Still, knowing about this all diminishes the appeal for me of getting Mythic the "proper" way. Probably I should just stop caring about pointless video game ranks, period, but I do still kinda wanna be Mythic someday. And I have fun playing good Magic.

Anyway, in the past, I've gotten close when I'm excited about a fun deck and dramatically scale up how much I play, which is otherwise not very frequently. I'm not currently in that state, but I probably will be at some point this year.

Previously, I've made markets for particular seasons (and got Mythic viscerally through @galen!)

So resolves YES when I hit Mythic on Magic The Gathering Arena, regardless of how well-deserved, and NO if it doesn't happen by year's end. Resolves N/A if the Mythic rank is abolished, but not if it's renamed and is functionally the same.

Betting policy: I won't bet very much. Probably just if the market feels very mispriced.

General policy for my markets: In the rare event of a conflict between my resolution criteria and the agreed-upon common-sense spirit of the market, I may resolve it according to the market's spirit or N/A, probably after discussion.

Get Ṁ200 play money

🏅 Top traders

#NameTotal profit
1Ṁ276
2Ṁ39
3Ṁ38
4Ṁ35
5Ṁ23
Sort by:
bought Ṁ50 of NO

Just some time discounting here. I haven't done any significant amount of Arena grinding this year.

predicted YES

I made it last year in the 3 or so days after getting hip surgery because it was the beginning of the cycle and I was playing like 8 hours a day. I wasn't even that good, I think its mostly a matter of exploiting the system.

predicted NO

@eulerphi yeahhh - the worry is maybe I can't pull that off because I've played for too long!

bought Ṁ13 of YES

@eulerphi I could have sworn I saw a thread somewhere talking about a player getting a warning or a ban for excessive conceding... although I can't find it right now and have no idea exactly how much conceding they were doing.

You can do it!

How many games did you play in the past seasons? Do you intend to play more in this season? Do you track your results and choose decks to play based on past win rate?

predicted NO

@GustavoMafra I don't really know. Maybe I should actually get one of those Arena trackers.

This particular season, I don't intend to play more. If I get Mythic it will happen later in the year.

bought Ṁ5 of YES

Oops I misread the market, I thought it was about this season only. Going to bet Yes on this since you reached Diamond 2 without any tracking and you have the rest of the year. Would bet more if this was conditional on some number of games played and if you didn't focus so much of the "deceitful & exploitable secret ranking"