[planecrash][rot13]Qvq Xrygunz qryvorengryl neenatr sbe Puryvnk gb qrgrezvar uvf vaibyirzrag va gur Juvfcrejbbq vapvqrag?
24
106
470
resolved Nov 11
Resolved
YES

Did Keltham deliberately arrange for Cheliax to determine his involvement in the Whisperwood incident?

Resolves to YES if this incident was staged for some effect on Cheliax.

Resolves to NO if the tiefling was an accident unpredicted by Keltham.

In case of ambiguity, I will resolve however I feel is least misleading, but cannot promise that there will be a clear answer.

Close date updated to 2023-12-31 11:59 pm

Get Ṁ200 play money

🏅 Top traders

#NameTotal profit
1Ṁ153
2Ṁ116
3Ṁ51
4Ṁ48
5Ṁ22
Sort by:

@AndrewHyer Can this resolve?

predicted YES

@EvanDaniel Sure.

In the absence of further evidence, I'm inclined to resolve to YES: if anyone disagrees with that, anticipates that an epilogue might change this, or wants to go bother the authors for a Word Of God answer, let me know.

Resolves to YES if this incident was staged for some effect on Cheliax.

Resolves to NO if the tiefling was an accident unpredicted by Keltham.

Can you clarify, how will you resolve in case:

  • Keltham did that for his own purposes (trying to figure out if he can chat with beings from beyond or smth), and NOT for its effect on Cheliax.

  • He correctly predicted that something like the tiefling accident could happen, and has taken no precaucions since he also predicted that Cheliax will have a hard time figuring out what that means, may confuse Cheliax, and it is not his main plot anyway, so it is not worth expending resources to heavily guard against Cheliax learning about this.

@theservy I will resolve that to NO. In that hypothetical, Keltham did not deliberately arrange for Cheliax to hear of it - he took fewer precautions because it wasn't important to him that they not hear of it, but the tiefling was a coincidence (albeit one that didn't bother him much)

[planecrash][rot13]Qvq Xrygunz qryvorengryl neenatr sbe Puryvnk gb qrgrezvar uvf vaibyirzrag va gur Juvfcrejbbq vapvqrag?, 8k, beautiful, illustration, trending on art station, picture of the day, epic composition