Skip to main content
MANIFOLD
Does manifold have an SEO spam problem?
15
Ṁ380Ṁ970
resolved Mar 10
Resolved
NO

Recent examples of SEO-farming spam questions:

https://manifold.markets/MichaelJose/take-my-online-course (https://web.archive.org/web/20240302112112/https://manifold.markets/MichaelJose/take-my-online-course)

https://manifold.markets/Rohitsharma1a63/glyco-guard-au-nz-glycogen-control

https://manifold.markets/Rohitsharma1a63/willie-nelson-cbd-gummies-truth-rev-ea8327a5da06 (added 2024-03-02T13:55:10Z)

https://manifold.markets/HalilDeutschmann/388betre (added 2024-03-03T20:58:22Z)

https://manifold.markets/nbettoday/nbettoday-f90e27d81005 (added 2024-03-04T12:07:02Z)

https://manifold.markets/nbettoday/nbettoday (added 2024-03-04T12:07:02Z)

"spam" is classified at my own discretion. This market lasts for a week, and will resolve as YES if I encounter more than 10 spam markets in my casual usage of Manifold.

I won't deliberately seek them out, but I'll edit to add them to the example list above, when I see them - so the current total is 6. They still count if a moderator subsequently deletes them.

I'll ignore comments that link to markets in this comment section - I'm only counting markets I encounter organically. I will not bet on this market.

Market context
Get
Ṁ1,000
to start trading!

🏅 Top traders

#TraderTotal profit
1Ṁ138
2Ṁ118
3Ṁ74
4Ṁ46
5Ṁ19
Sort by:

This one surprised me actually - I haven't seen any spam for the last several days. I wonder if there was actually a reduction, or just luck based on when I was checking for new markets

reposted

<1h left 👀

Just to be clear, I didn't forget about this market or anything, the current total is still 6

Current total is up to 6 👀

Kinda sad I said I wouldn't bet on this myself because I think I know which way it's gonna go

not seen any spam in the past couple of days!

"Does manifold have an SEO spam problem?" — I think it does

"will resolve as YES if I encounter more than 10 spam markets in my casual usage of Manifold" — depends heavily what is your casual usage of Manifold.

yup - it's hard to quantify what my usage looks like but my profile page might be informative

I have been wondering why the links are dofollow on most markets but nofollow on others (unlisted ones presumably). Manifold should probably make links nofollow by default (perhaps until the market becomes popular, like Reddit does).

Also wondering: are those bot submissions? Is someone in the black hat SEO-sphere curating a list of sites where dofollow links can be posted?

@lukres Manifold uses a bunch of filters for actions that only spam accounts make (like making a market but never betting) to try to guess whether an account is spam.

bought Ṁ30 YES

I see many more than that, but I'm also a mod so 🤷