In the absence of the creator @love , the criteria are too vague to infer exactly how they would have resolved. The write up from @Agh seems reasonable so I will resolve N/A. If @love comes back within a week and wants to resolve it differently, we will defer to them, but otherwise this will stand as N/A.

This is one problem with vague markets that can be tough to overcome.

Wife meant years of investment. He didn't give a f about max as much as he did Melina

How many hours of stream time did the Mr Girl falling out take up? Ten? Twenty? Thirty? Forty? The Destiny/Melina falling out barely even has a back and forth

@love how you feeling about this so far?

@Agh the user seems to be gone, do you have any input?

@Eliza this one is tough because Destiny broke up with his wife, which is pretty huge. But the mrgirl drama was pretty huge too. It involved multiple people and there was a 50 pages long hit piece. I would have to think about it.

@Agh Since you have already sold your position, I'm delegating the resolution to you unless @love shows up again. I'm sure you can come up with a reasoned result.

@Eliza sure

@Agh Melina won drama of the year, notably

@Tumbles yeah, but that's more of a popularity contest.

@Agh Ya I voted for Mr Girl LOL

There's two ways to interpret which falling-out is larger.

1. The person who is lost is of bigger importance, the hole in your heart is bigger.

2. The drama is more extensive, more intense and drawn out.

The marriage drama clears criteria 1 easily, but the mrgirl drama wins by criteria 2 (it split the subreddit, it involved multiple orbiters, mrgirl contacted every woman in destiny's life and wrote a 100k word manifesto)

I lean towards criteria 2 being more important, but a lot of people here definitely judged the market more by criteria 1 (and the marriage drama won the dgg awards after all).

--------

@Eliza

In the end I recommend an N/A resolution, because the market was too vaguely defined. A YES or NO solution would not be fair to the opposite site just because they interpreted the vague criteria in a different but totally understandable way.

Vague question. What would it take for you to determine it was larger than the Mrgirl fallout?

@marketman if destiny states that it is of proportions larger than mr. girl