🏅 Top traders

Let’s see if community management believes makers can override title/description criteria in a comment

@ElmerFudd Manifold staff let market creators get away with too much stuff imo

@ShadowyZephyr Yikes. I don’t want to cost innocent traders mana. I hope admins will resolve NA or Yes after I resolve No. If they don’t I guess manifold policy really is that comments override title/description.

@DavidChee should I have lost half my portfolio, my all time profits and my league standing because I didn’t consider that the maker could’ve changed the criteria in a long-buried comment when I invested?

@ElmerFudd it seems a little reckless to pour that much of your portfolio into a single market without bothering to read the author's comments on the market

@MarcusAbramovitch I didn’t think makers could change the explicit criteria in the title/description in the comments. I won’t tag you know who again, but I want him to clarify if that’s manifold policy.

@ElmerFudd Mistakes were made in this market. Both by the author and by traders.

@ShadowyZephyr I don’t think I was mistaken to invest here. There’s alpha between 97% and 100%. I don’t blame the maker for sticking with their old comment - some traders back in March invested on the basis of that comment. But admins should’ve resolved NA, unless manifold takes the position that comments can override the title/description.

I agree, but it should've been resolved N/A a long time ago. But it wasn't, people kept betting on it with the new & different resolution criteria.

@ElmerFudd Manifold's main policy is that market creator usually has the call

Hmm..

I'm not quite enough of a whale. :3

Only lost 1.4k mana 🙏

This market is misresolved according to the initial name, description, and the market creator’s comment

@ms LOL. How many are gonna say this??

@BTE If only we could bet on it…

I definitely need that mana back like right now so I am extremely tempted. Why did you give me all of this resolution power only for it to be a tease when I really want to use it?!?! @Austin @ian @DavidChee

@BTE The market creator is active, you'll have to wait a bit :)

@BTE you're basically wearing a digital chastity cage 🐓

@higherLEVELING It’s got my mana hood !!

should i just do it

@MarcusAbramovitch I will if you don’t! LOL!!

@MarcusAbramovitch please!

@MarcusAbramovitch please do.

@MarcusAbramovitch @BTE the market creator has (understandably) gone inactive this last month so I wouldn't hold out hope for a quick or timely resolve to NO here.

EDIT - I was totally mistaken. Apologies!

@Lorxus That’s not true. They have been increasingly active for the last week or so in fact. I think prior to that they may have been MIA for awhile.