Skip to main content
MANIFOLD
Is it possible Hamas has hundreds of militants in the United States ready to bomb hospitals and blow up schools
37
Ṁ750Ṁ961
resolved Oct 18
Resolved
N/A

Charlie Kirk, the pro-Trump activist who hosts a nationally syndicated radio show, floated the idea on his program. “It’s possible Hamas has hundreds or thousands of militants on the interior of the United States ready to bomb hospitals, blow up schools, or just rain terror.”

Market context
Get
Ṁ1,000
to start trading!
Sort by:
predictedNO

Am I right that this poor posting goes away on 23 October ?

predictedYES

@VIncentArguimbau The market will be closed, but you will still have to resolve. You can resolve right now. Just click on the resolve button and choose NA. This way everyone will get their mana back.

predictedNO

@MaxTroet Thanks

I've thought about this question. In my opinion, this market should be resolved with "N/A", because the question doesn't suit the format. Technically "yes" is the right answer. The question is not about the probability of this scenario. We're all in agreement that it's improbable. The question is about whether it's possible. As unlikely as it may seem, it is virtually impossible to prove that Hamas does not have ''hundreds of militants'' in the United States. As long as we can't prove that, the possibility, dwindlingly small as it may be, will always remain.

I can't think of any scenario that would allow us to resolve with "no", other than the US or Hamas ceasing to exist.

@MaxTroet yes poorly phrased question.

In my opinion, it's not possible to falsify this assumption, which is why a political charlatan like Charlie Kirk can get away with claiming such nonsense.

predictedNO

@MaxTroet I thought the purpose of this market was to discredit a loony like Kirk

@VIncentArguimbau That's an approach. I'm new to this as well. I've seen other markets with a note like "will never resolve". Maybe that's the right way to do it?

predictedNO

@MaxTroet I think this market is useful for determining odds of open ended events as described in the book Superforecasting as well as those that end with a date certain election

@VIncentArguimbau Ratio the madness

predictedNO

Resolve? That not my job

@VIncentArguimbau It is. Please look into how this works.

predictedNO

@MaxTroet Look where?

@NicoDelon If you have no plan to resolve this market you should cancel it (resolve NA).

predictedNO

@NicoDelon You are right, I should delist my account immediately

@VIncentArguimbau That works too. And/or you can simply add to your description that your market will never resolve.

@NicoDelon I think he's being sarcastic? 😅

Resolution criteria?

Anything is possible. But how do you plan to resolve this?